After Action Recommendations for the Raleigh Police Department

After Action Recommendations for the Raleigh Police Department

WEB EXCLUSIVE Following the police brutality—including the use of tear gas—that ensued after peaceful protests in downtown Raleigh in May after the death of George Floyd, the Raleigh Police Department underwent an independent review of their practices, policies and procedures on the use of force and their response to protests and mass gatherings by 21CP Solutions, a group that “helps law enforcement agencies and communities effectively tackle the challenges of policing in the 21st century.” Last week, 21CP Solutions released their report, which also included several after-action recommendations for the RPD. 

21CP says they used information and data provided by RPD, RPD personnel in focus groups and community members to conduct the final report, which they also note was not an independent after-action report, nor were they charged with conducting an independent investigation on what did and did not occur during the protests. 21CP then formulated recommendations for future issues based on RPD’s existing policies and national practices.

The report outlines a total of 38 recommendations across eight categories. Below, we summarize key points in each of these eight categories. (According to 21CP Solutions, recommendations are not ranked in any specific order.)

Operational Planning

RPD training records obtained by 21CP showed that RPD provides crowd management and incident command training to officers within the National Incident Management System (“NIMS”) framework RPD uses to manage large and complex events. However, 21CP recommends that the police department train additional commanders that are more capable of handling large police actions during critical incidents, and have all officers undergo Mobile Field Force (MFF) and Crowd Management training. 21CP also recommends that whenever RPD gets word of an organized protest, they develop an Incident Action Plan, which would help them effectively manage any civil disorder and subsequent action like arrests. Additionally, this category sheds light on the City of Raleigh’s picket or protest permitting ordinance that requires an application to be approved by the Chief of Police, which 21CP recommends both the city and RPD start enforcing.

Use of Force and De-escalation During Protests

RPD’s policy on the use of force and weapons as of March 26, 2020 stated that “force should be used only when all other means of resolving a situation have been exhausted or are clearly inapplicable” and should only be used when “reasonably necessary to control a situation.” Through interviews with Raleigh community voices, RPD’s After Action Report and video footage, 21CP found that RPD deployed several munitions, including tear gas, foam batons and rubber bullets, on the nights of May 30 and 31. 

In their report, 21CP recommends that RPD develop a more clear and specific guidelines on when the use of force is okay in crowd contexts and re-train commanders on when and how to deploy special munitions, including in what circumstances RPD should deploy tear gas. 21CP suggests that RPD find a way to document the use of tear gas, foam batons and/or projectiles for accountability purposes.

Equipment and Resources

Through interviews with RPD, 21CP found that many of the police department’s gas canisters were expired. 21CP recommends that the police department keep an inventory of their equipment to ensure their effectiveness and, should they continue to use chemical munitions, their supply be “vetted for quality and usability.” Additionally, 21CP suggests RPD look into using “soft” protective equipment for Mobile Field Force personnel, which offers similar protection provided by the gear currently worn by RPD’s MFF squads without the intimidating “militarized” look. It may also be helpful, according to 21CP, for RPD to look into CCTV cameras, aerial support and intelligence, small utility vehicles like Gators and sound amplification devices in department-issued gas masks.

Communications

21CP Solutions noted that communicating with staff is extremely important when planning for a large-scale event or a critical incident response. They recommended that RPD develop a strategy to communicate clearly and effectively what they expect from MFF during a protest that could potentially turn violent. 21CP said that, through interviews with RPD stakeholders, they discerned that there was no communication strategy in place before the protests on May 30 and 31. 21CP also suggested that there be a debriefing after protest, crowd management and critical incident management shifts.

Mutual Aid

During the nights of May 30 and May 31, RPD obtained mutual aid from ten different jurisdictions. 21CP recommends RPD review their existing Mutual Aid Agreements and reach out to local and county law enforcement agencies that may be able to offer further protection or resources to them; all agreements should be reviewed annually.

Body Worn Cameras 

Nationally, the use of body worn cameras by police officers has increased greatly in recent years. According to an RPD camera policy provided to 21CP, “the use of body worn cameras is prohibited during many protest situations.” 21CP recommends that RPD review this policy to ensure that its requirements are  clear within the contexts of protests and crowd management. 21CP also suggests that RPD establish a committee that would convene to manage training, implementation and maintenance of body cameras.

After Action Reports

21CP defines an After Action Report (AAR) as a “process in which ‘following a project or event,’ an organization and its ‘members gather to share insights and identify mistakes and successes.” They recommend that both stakeholders inside and outside of the Raleigh Police Department are involved in the After Action Review process and that all After Action Reports filed detail actions, responsibilities and timeframes, as well as recommendations for future events. The police chief should ensure these actions are being implemented within a regular report.

Community Engagement

21CP recommends that after large protests and other incidents, the community should be able to debrief with the department to express any  personal experiences or concerns. A third party can further help with communication between police and the community in order to deter violence or conflict. Additionally, RPD should utilize their social media accounts for communicating with protesters and other community members during critical events.

View 21CP Solutions full report of the Raleigh Police Department following the protests in May here.

Messages in Murals

Messages in Murals

WEB EXCLUSIVE The fight for voting rights for African Americans and people of color, as well as for racial equality, has been going on since even before the 1960s, when mass civil rights protests broke out over the right for equal rights for Black people as well as for their right to vote. Though the 15th Amendment prevents the federal government from denying any citizens the right to vote, ingrained racism and voter suppression targeting people of color has become even more apparent in the electoral system as of late.

Renowned artist Shepard Fairey believes voting rights are human rights, and that everyone should have equal voting access regardless of race or economic circumstance. In an effort to share this message on a larger scale, he collaborated with photographer Steve Schapiro, who documented many important civil rights protests in the 1960s, on a new 18-foot high mural for the exterior of the Cortez restaurant on Glenwood Avenue. The work, titled “Voting Rights are Human Rights,” was also created in response to George Floyd’s murder.

Photo by Joshua Steadman

Wyatt Closs of Big Bowl of Ideas, a creative production company that collaborates on projects surrounding themes of social justice, selected Fairey’s art for a national project called “Walls for Black Lives.” The project will support a national day of strike for Black lives on July 20. As part of the project, eight cities around the country—including Raleigh—now feature artworks supporting the Black Lives Matter movement.

Closs says he chose Raleigh as one of the participating cities because of its notoriety. “[Raleigh] is a flashpoint for voting rights and the minimum wage is too low, both of which disproportionately impact Black people, a metaphorical set of ‘knees to the neck’ for African Americans generally,” Closs says.

“Voting Rights are Human Rights” is Fairey’s first large-scale installation in Raleigh. Closs says the mural should last at least a month, but he hopes it can last until Election Day on November 3—because of the medium of the artwork, it’s hard to predict how long it will last. Raleigh Murals Project secured the location and local artists Taylor White and Sarahlaine Calva installed the mural at Cortez.

Closs says he hopes Fairey’s mural will make Raleighites pause and contemplate what’s going on in the world right now. “It’s really a message to folks that, not just that Black lives matter, but it’s important to channel the energy from [the strike] into civic engagement and voter participation and be a voice for change,” Closs says.

Fairey also created the Barack Obama “Hope” poster for Obama’s 2008 presidential campaign. In Wisconsin, Fairey will paint the same “Voting Rights are Human Rights” mural on the south side of the 12-story Railway Exchange building in downtown Milwaukee, which served as the city’s headquarter’s for President Obama’s 2012 reelection campaign. The piece is expected to be completed in time for the Democratic National Convention in mid-August.

How to Be a Part of the Solution: Black Lives Matter Resources

How to Be a Part of the Solution: Black Lives Matter Resources

(Illustration by Jane Mount)

WEB EXCLUSIVE In the wake of protests against police brutality, white supremacy and racist policies, Americans have taken to the streets to demonstrate peacefully and call for change. But there is a lot more many of us can do to inform ourselves about these issues and what needs to be different. We’ve curated a list of ways folks can educate themselves about the history of racism and white supremacy in America as well as ways they can support the Black Lives Matter movement. Additionally, here are some local resources and ways to be supportive.

Where to Donate

Contribute to the fight for equality and human rights.

American Civil Liberties Union – aclu.org
The Bail Project Fund bailproject.org
Black Visions Collective – blackvisionsmn.org
Campaign Zero – joincampaignzero.org/#campaign
Color of Change – colorofchange.org
Fair Fight – fairfight.com
Minnesota Freedom Fund – minnesotafreedomfund.org
NAACP – secure.actblue.com/donate/naacp-1
Official George Floyd Memorial Fund gofundme.com/f/georgefloyd 

What to Watch/Read

Educate yourself on the history of racism in America and the Black Lives Matter movement.

WATCH:
13th
American Son
Clemency
Dear White People
Explained: The Racial Wealth Gap
LA 92
Time: The Kalief Browder Story
When They See Us
Who Killed Malcom X?

READ:
The 1619 Project
“Americanah” by Chimamanda Ngozi Adichie
“The Autobiography of Malcolm X” by Malcolm X
“Barracoon: The Story of the ‘Last Black Cargo’” by Zora Neale Hurston
“Between the World and Me” by Ta-Nehisi Coates
“Blindspot: Hidden Biases of Good People” by Anthony Greenwald and Mahzarin Banaji
“Brit(ish)” by Afua Hirsch
“Chokehold: Policing Black Men” by Paul Butler
“Citizen: An American Lyric” by Claudia Rankine
“The Color of Law” by Richard Rothstein
“Faces at the Bottom of the Well: The Permanence of Racism” by Derrick Bell
“The Blood of Emmett Till” by Timothy B. Tyson
“The Fire Next Time” by James Baldwin
“The Fire This Time” by Jesmyn Ward
“Girl, Woman, Other” by Bernardine Evaristo
“The Good Immigrant: 26 Writers Reflect on America” by Nikesh Shukla
“Heavy: An American Memoir” by Kiese Laymon
“How To Be An Antiracist” by Ibram X. Kendi
“How We Fight for Our Lives” by Saeed Jones
“How We Fight White Supremacy” by Akiba Solomon
“I’m Still Here” by Austin Channing Brown
“Just Mercy: A Story of Justice and Redemption” by Bryan Stevenson
“Malcolm X: A Life of Reinvention” by Manning Marable
“Me and White Supremacy” by Layla Saad
“Mindful of Race” by Ruth King
“The New Jim Crow: Mass Incarceration in the Age of Colorblindness” by Michelle Alexander
“Slavery By Another Name” by Douglas A. Blackmon
“So You Want to Talk About Race” by Ijeoma Oluo
“Stamped from the Beginning” by Ibram X Kendi
“Stamped: Racism, Anti-Racism and You” by Ibram X Kendi and Jason Reynolds
“Their Eyes Were Watching God” by Zora Neale Hurston
“Why I’m No Longer Talking to White People about Race” by Reni Eddo-Lodge
“White Fragility” by Robin Diangelo

Who to Support

Support the Black Lives Matter movement through these organizations.

Black Lives Matter – blacklivesmatter.com 
Justice for Breonna – justiceforbreonna.org
Run With Maud – runwithmaud.com
Unicorn Riot unicornriot.ninja

Who to Follow

Black Lives Matter – @blklivesmatter
Benjamin Crump – @attorneycrump
Color of Change – @colorofchange
Equal Justice Initiative – @eji_org
NAACP – @naacp
Rachel Cargle – @rachel.cargle
Reclaim the Block – @reclaimtheblock
The Leadership Conference on Civil and Human Rights – @civilrightsorg
United We Dream – @unitedwedream

Who to Text

Sign these petitions to demand justice for Black victims of police brutality.

Text FLOYD to 55-156
Text JUSTICE to 66-8336
Test ENOUGH to 55-165

How to Take Action

Register to vote.
Check in on your black family members, friends, colleagues and partners.
Educate yourself about what it means to be anti-racist.
Share resources with those around you.
Be an ally.

Know of some other resources or ways to be helpful? Email us.

Protests and Unrest: Three Nights in Downtown Raleigh

Protests and Unrest: Three Nights in Downtown Raleigh

WEB EXCLUSIVE George Floyd’s brutal murder by a white police officer in Minneapolis one week ago—on top of countless other incidents of racist violence against Black people in America—triggered protests in cities across the nation.

This weekend, those protests came to Raleigh.

What began as peaceful demonstrations downtown on both Saturday and Sunday evenings devolved into chaos after sundown. Police officers fired tear gas and rubber bullets at demonstrators. Looters destroyed storefronts, businesses and city property on Fayetteville, Wilmington and Salisbury streets. Raleighites were left to pick up the pieces, prepare for more unrest and, in the long run, seek out ways to heal deep racial divisions and to try to figure out how to build a more equitable city.

Here, we try to piece together what happened this weekend from the differing perspectives of demonstrators, police, activists, media outlets, business owners and other observers.

Saturday Evening

Several activist groups call for peaceful demonstrations to demand justice for George Floyd, Breonna Taylor, Ahmed Arbery and those killed by police officers in Raleigh. Protesters are asked to wear face masks and bring posters and water.

Local activist groups including Raleigh PACT, Young Americans Protest and Carolina Peace Center release a list of demands, including a police review board with subpoena power, restoration of CACs, closing police stations in black communities and policies requiring police officers to intervene when they witness police abuse. They call for the removal of Police Chief Cassandra Deck-Brown if their demands are not met.

By 6 p.m., following a march into downtown via Capital Boulevard, up to 3,000 demonstrators gather in front of the Wake County Courthouse. They listen to speakers, hold signs, chant and rally peaceably in honor of George Floyd’s memory.

Then, something changes. Demonstrators say police start using tear gas on the crowd.

View this post on Instagram

I don’t expect any of you to understand if you weren’t out there these past two nights, we are peaceful and have been through the entirety of this protest. The police in this town are attacking us for using our first amendment rights and protesting when just a few weeks ago they were armed white men walking through the streets without a problem. 5 minutes into getting out there at 5:00 p.m. today unprovoked they shot tear gas at us a rubber bullet flew by me and my friend’s head we could hear and feel the power going behind it, if that had hit any of us we wouldn’t be here to tell the story. The cops are attacking us for no reason other than the fact we are protesting their corrupt organization. It’s hard to believe I know, I wouldn’t want to so I understand where you’re coming from, but I need you to hear and to know the truth is that the Raleigh police department and any others out there with them are attacking us for being out there, for protesting against their organization and the crimes that they have committed over the years, they are out there to hurt us and stop our voice from being heard. I will not stop going out there until I deem it unsafe, not from us the protesters but because they have decided to use a live ammo on us, I know that sounds crazy but they started tonight. Close your eyes as tight as you can it doesn’t change what is going on in our city and the one over all the way across this land. The system is broken they kill people everyday without a care. I have been out there for two straight nights, I have been hit with gases, I’ve watched people get hit with these rubber bullets, there is a war going on in our streets, and we are defenseless, they are the ones causing this, unless you were there you won’t be able to understand but know that this is the truth. Remember which side you choose to stand with, when this is said and done. No matter what they’ve thrown at us we will prevail, our voices will not go unheard and the unjust system that is running our country and killing our brothers and sisters will have fallen, I full heartedly believe this, I can’t not fight for this. #justiceforfloyd #justiceforbreonnataylor #blacklivesmatter

A post shared by Michael (@_mwoodhouse) on

Here is how the News and Observer describes what happened:

This is what happened according to Chief Deck-Brown.

Many of the demonstrators begin to leave as the sun sets. The situation worsens.

Looters begin breaking glass windows of downtown storefronts with bricks. The CVS pharmacy at the corner of Hargett and Fayetteville streets is broken into and set ablaze.

There are reports of white supremacist groups infiltrating the protest and rioting. White supremacist symbols are found spray painted onto downtown buildings.

Sunday Morning

Downtown Raleigh is in bad shape following chaos that lasted long into the night.

Volunteers show up early to help with the cleanup.

Here are some reactions from downtown business owners.

View this post on Instagram

As I held my 6-week old son in my arms soothing him back to sleep, I received a phone call that our downtown Raleigh shop was currently being looted & vandalized. . I turned to social media and looked at the countless images of broken glass of our small business neighbors storefronts, spray-painted walls on our mom & pop shops, our beautiful city trashed and my community hurting. . As a black small business owner, I am devastated by this footage, harshly written graffiti downtown, and how our small business community has yet another setback while during a pandemic that has closed & stopped all of our incomes. . As a black small business owner, I am devastated by how our peaceful protest just to live is now going to be overshadowed by the few people who are looting and breaking glass. . I am frustrated that it has come to this because of systemic racism & oppression nationwide and hurt with my people. . We will be closed in downtown Raleigh today (Sunday) while we pick up the pieces and process this mental game brewing in my mind. . I am sure I will have more to say on this but right now, I am rocking my son back to sleep, and enjoying the warmth of him in my arms. . – Megan

A post shared by The ZEN Succulent® (@thezensucculent) on

View this post on Instagram

Yesterday brought a powerful movement of people united in pursuit of justice and equality to Downtown Raleigh. For hours, protestors peacefully gathered in the heart of Raleigh to have their voices heard. Today we picked up the pieces of chaos that others brought overnight and were thankful for the safety of our loved ones. Damage can be fixed, things can be replaced, but lives are precious. The pain can not be ignored. Our hearts are saddened by the hurt in our country right now, but to see our community come together today was a beautiful sight. An incredible thank you for the outpouring of love from all that checked in and came out to lend a hand. We are so proud to be a part of the Downtown Raleigh community. ❤️

A post shared by ORO Restaurant & Lounge (@oro_restaurant) on

Raleigh Mayor Mary-Ann Baldwin holds a press conference Sunday afternoon and releases a statement addressing the events of Saturday night.

Gov. Roy Cooper has this to say.

Sunday Evening

Activists organize another peaceful demonstration downtown. Demonstrators gather near the State Capitol and the Governor’s Mansion.

But conflict with police again breaks out, with officers deploying tear gas on the demonstrators.

This is RPD’s explanation for using tear gas.

There are more reports of rabble rousing from outside agitators.

And more reports of looting and destruction, including at North Hills and Triangle Town Center.

Late Sunday evening, law enforcement officers are shown on video shooting at a downtown business owner.

Monday Morning

With protests showing no sign of abating, Baldwin institutes a citywide curfew beginning at 8 p.m. RPD says the National Guard has been deployed to restore order.

Baldwin is criticized for “official incompetence” in an N&O editorial for not implementing a curfew sooner.

Chief Deck-Brown is criticized for, among other perceived missteps, not instructing officers to protect property and businesses.

RPD is criticized for, among other perceived missteps, reacting overly aggressively towards demonstrators, especially compared to how officers treated demonstrators carrying firearms around downtown last month.

Monday Evening

Around 5 p.m., several hundred demonstrators march downtown from the Bell Tower on Hillsborough Street.

By 9 p.m., the crowd has dispersed peacefully. Raleigh’s streets are empty.

Header photo from @BriannaABaker