by Jane Porter | Jun 25, 2019 | City Council
The City Council has proposed putting an affordable housing bond on the ballot next year. Do you support the bond and do you think that’s enough to address Raleigh’s affordable housing problem?
The answer to that is no, that’s not enough, and I like to say we can’t buy our way out of this crisis. And it is a looming crisis. I’ve come up with a ten point plan that addresses what I believe is needed. No. 1 is policy. We need policy changes, planning and leadership. The ten point plan really starts with leadership and education, telling people why this is important and what the consequences are if we don’t build more housing stock. I’m advocating for ADUs by right. I think people should have a choice in whether they want to age in place, have an aging parent come live with them or even house a boomerang kid who has a bunch of college debt and no place to stay. It just gives people choices and that’s one of many components. The second thing is missing middle housing. Right now in Raleigh, if you tear down a duplex you cannot rebuild it. You have to build one house. So you’re losing stock just based on the fact that you can’t replenish it with a duplex or triplex or townhouse or whatever. We really need to look at missing middle housing and how we can change our zoning to allow for more flexibility. I’m also an advocate for cottage courts and tiny homes. That was something I had been working on before I left the Council and the whole tiny home discussion went away after I left. Again, it is just different types of housing, different types of choices. Minimum lot sizes, there needs to be a reduction in that because that is one of the things encouraging McMansions. And I think we need to reduce the parking requirements because that adds to the cost of housing. Anything we can do to reduce the cost is important. On the inter-city visit, we learned Seattle was working with the county and the schools to look at identifying underutilized properties and then either releasing that to the private development community for affordable housing or doing housing themselves. That is something we should take a look at here. If the schools say they have some excess property on a school site, why couldn’t we build, say, a teachers village there. If the county or city has property that’s underutilized, could we build something like what the salvation army has on Capital Boulevard, a place to house women and children or veterans? Those are two huge needs. We just have to be creative and work together. Obviously, up-zoning for density, that’s where the planning comes in. We have to look at all our transit corridors and we have to stop treating developers like they’re the enemy and figure out how we can work in partnership and what kinds of incentives we could work with. For instance, land swaps—maybe a developer owns property here but they own property in another spot; could they build affordable housing in that other spot for rezoning? Could we look at gap funding, TIF financing, expedited approvals? We need to get together with the development community and pull together a panel and identify what’s possible. Then, we need to partner with a land trust, that is something we haven’t done and really need to do. Then, a well crafted bond. That means we need to engage the community, plan accordingly and poll to determine the dollar value.
Raleigh’s Human Relations Commission recently recommended the city set up a police oversight board with investigative and subpoena powers. Raleigh’s Police Chief has stated she is not in favor of such a board. Does Raleigh need a board for police oversight?
There are a couple of things at play here. No. 1, we need to do a better job of communicating with all different groups within the city. We started what we called “community conversations” and we should have kept that going. We started it and people never felt heard so the communication piece is really important. Community policing is really important, so people get to know each other and it’s not just “Oh, there’s a bad guy, or there’s a cop;” it’s like, “Here’s people trying to work together to do good and then there are people who care about their community.” As far as a police oversight board is concerned, we need to do something. But I am not willing to go to the General Assembly and ask them for permission to set up a police oversight board with subpoena powers. That could backfire and you could end up with something you don’t want. I wold rather we figure out something that works for Raleigh and I believe we can do that through conversation, and being open to various ideas. Any time the General Assembly gets involved, you just don’t know what that could end up looking like. I’m not willing to take that chance.
John Kane has proposed building a 40 story tower in the Peace Street area downtown. If elected Mayor, would you support the rezoning for that proposal as is, or try to negotiate for inclusion of affordable hosing units?
That’s my neighborhood and I would look out at that every single day. People in the neighborhood are actually very supportive of this. We have been waiting for development in that part of downtown for a long time. It is totally underutilized, totally underdeveloped and totally under-resourced. This particular development sits on a Bus Rapid Transit transit line. It will be next to a cycle track which will connect to a greenway. The city has just invested $10 million in new intersections in that area to alleviate traffic so if we can’t build something there, I don’t know where we can build it in the city. I am totally in favor of that. Back to incentive piece, we need to get creative with incentives and it shouldn’t just be beating [developers] over the head and saying if you put affordable housing there, you can get this rezoning. We need to be more creative than that and work with developers in different ways.
Does Raleigh have enough density and do we currently have the infrastructure to support more?
It can be kind of a chicken and the egg thing. Do we have the infrastructure, yes, I think we do but the way to get better infrastructure is to look at more mobility choices. If you have people biking to work, you need less parking and it alleviates traffic. If you have people taking a bus to work, a Bus Rapid Transit line, that is going to do the same thing. If you make streets more walkable, people can walk places; density allows that, it creates those walkable communities. I don’t think we have enough density and the core is where density belongs. There are also opportunities for density along different corridors, whether it’s Wilmington Street, South Saunders Street, Blount Street… places close to downtown offer a lot of opportunities. When I first ran for City Council 12 years ago, everybody was talking about sprawl, how it’s bad. Now, everybody is anti-density and you can’t have it both ways. It’s not anti-this or that, it is, “yeah, we have to have density, but in the right areas, and when we think about it, that is also how we’re going to reduce congestion and create better environmental conditions.”
CACs (neighborhood meetings) have traditionally been ways for citizens to engage with decisions that will go before the City Council. Do you support CACs or do you think, with a lot of these conversations happening online these days, that CACs have outlasted their usefulness?
CACs have value but I don’t think they should be the only form of citizen engagement. When you have eight people at a CAC meeting making a decision abut a zoning case, that’s not representative of the community. Young people will watch something on Facebool Live, they’ll watch digital streaming. If you have a young child at home, going to a 7 o’clock city meeting is not on your top list of activities but if you have an opportunity to engage from your living room, that is the missing piece, the technology. The city did an outstanding job of engagement on Dix Park and that should offer some type of blueprint. We had a citizen engagement task force that looked at options and came back with some great ideas but there was resistance on the part of CACs. The CACs need to be open to being more inclusive and including others in newer ways and that’s really important. Young people need to have their voices heard, renters need to have their voices heard, people of color need to have their voices heard. One of the gentlemen who is an expert in this field, who spoke to the Council about engagement, basically said the people who show up at meetings are 50 year old white homeowners. When I looked out in the audience, that’s who was sitting there. So he nailed that. We have to look for ways to be more inclusive and also to offer engagement in Spanish language. That is really important, to make sure others feel welcome as well.
Are the current members of the City Council putting forward a strong enough vision for Raleigh’s growth?
I don’t think they have a vision. The vision is “No, we want things to stay the way they are.” Raleigh is going to grow whether people like it or not. I don’t want us to end up like Seattle with two hour commutes and the average price of a home inching up to a million dollars. We can do better than that but we have to act with urgency. We have to have that vision. I talk about my vision for the City Council as being one of progress, innovation and compassion. Progress is advancing the things that are important: housing affordability, transportation, caring for our homeless. The innovation piece is embracing new ideas, new technology, proactively managing that and looking for new ideas within government to do things different ways. We shouldn’t be afraid of that, we should embrace it. Compassion is obvious, taking care of the people who need our help the most. That, to me, is one of the most important things we can do as a city.
Are the city managers and staff doing a good job implementing the Council’s vision as stated and running the day to day operations of the city?
We have one of the best staffs in the country. We have really smart people working for us. One of the major problems we have right now is that City Council has engaged in a war with staff. They are belittled, they are shamed, they are attacked. That is totally inappropriate behavior. I would challenge anybody to want to work under those circumstances. I know if I came to work every day and my boss publicly shamed me, I would be devastated. Those are the kind of conditions people are working under right now. The problem is the City Council is interfering in staff work. They are supposed to set policy and the vision, the staff is supposed to execute. It is really hard to execute a vision that doesn’t exist but it is also really hard to execute and do your job or feel empowered to do your job when you’re going to get cut down. That has to stop. There is a code of conduct and we need to look at that code of conduct and call out people or set up policies saying “no, this isn’t allowed” and just stop the bad behavior. I feel very strongly about that.
Recently, the Council passed a suite of rules regulating Airbnb and electric scooters. Do you support the rules or feel they are too strict?
This goes back to the whole idea of supporting innovative ideas and new ideas. First off, the rules are way too strict. When I chaired the Law and Public Safety Committee, we probably had close to 75 people who came to a number of meetings we held on the short-term rental issue. The majority were in favor. There may have been one or two people who had concerns. And then the hotel/motel industry had concerns. Their No. 1 concern was taxes. We worked with Airbnb and they immediately started taking out taxes to address that issue so that came off the table. The other concerns expressed, we dealt with in a very fair way. We said let’s form a registry, we’ll charge people to join the registry so we know who is a short-term rental, we know who is a long-term rental and we can deal with the problem appropriately. If you wanted to rent a full house, you had to get a special use permit, which meant your neighbors would have to be notified and you would have to follow certain criteria. The third thing we said was “Let’s initiate a three strikes and you’re out rule.” So, if a problem is reported at your short-term rental, you pay a fine. Second time, you pay a bigger fine. Third time, you’re not allowed to operate and if you do, you’re fined excessively. So that’s shutting down bad behavior. The current rules just shut down Airbnb. To say you can’t rent your house, or somebody coming here can’t rent a house, that’s just short-sighted. People come here for weddings, for the Bluegrass Fest, they come as families, for graduations. People need to feel that they’re welcomed in this city and that they can find a reasonably priced place to stay. Some people also come because they’re looking to move here. What does it say if they can’t try out a neighborhood? It doesn’t send the right message and it hurts tourism. As far as scooters are concerned, they are great. They increase accessibility throughout the city. The Council should have said “You cant drive a scooter on a sidewalk in the core of downtown; if you do, you’ll get fined” and they will enforce it. End of problem.
Last Word
Housing affordability is the No. 1 challenge and we need to address that in sync with transportation and transit because all of it is intertwined. To be successful in growing the city, in the way we want to see it grow, those are the two main issues I will focus on. When I talk about transportation and mobility, I’m talking about choices. It’s more than just commuter rail, which is really important to help with the gridlock that now exists on I-40 ,but also creating more walkable communities, protected bike lanes. People would ride more bikes if they felt safer so it comes down to all of the choices.
by Jane Porter | Jun 25, 2019 | City Council
The City Council has proposed putting an affordable housing bond on the ballot next year. Do you support the bond and do you think that’s enough to address Raleigh’s affordable housing problem?
Affordable housing is one of the top issues in the city, if not the top issue. I stressed it in 2017 and I’m going to be talking about it a lot in this campaign and emphasizing it as Mayor. I do support an affordable housing bond. The exact amount of the bond, I’m not sure. The important thing is what we do with the money. It costs $140, $150, $160 thousand to build an apartment so it’s not practical for the city to use the money to build apartments. Usually, the way you’re using that money is as a subsidy for private development. For example, what you want is for the private sector to have affordable units like people have talked about in some of the market rate buildings downtown, so you’re layering in different subsidies. The effective way to use that city bond money is to subsidize the private market to include affordable units. Much more than a bond is going to be required. One of the things I proposed is that, immediately, we will set up a task force of developers interested in building affordable housing, bankers, bond attorneys, tax attorneys, activists on the issue and come up with five to 10 things we can do right away that will have an impact. That includes a housing bond, it includes expanding tax credits on development, includes increasing density in areas where we need to have more density like downtown, like the places where the boulevards meet 440, but it can’t just be density, it needs to be density with diversity and density with ethics so we find a way for different people to live in these dense areas. It shouldn’t just be only density for high income people, it needs to be density that also includes affordable housing. Another thing we need to do is to remove some of the unnecessary impediments in the development process that slow it down and make it more expensive unnecessarily. I will give one example: the site plan review process is too cumbersome. The city staff very often takes too long in giving endless rounds of comments back to people developing properties which adds time and expense to development which is passed along to renters or to buyers. So we need to increase the stock of accessible housing, I won’t say affordable housing, but accessible housing both to rent and to buy. One of the things highlighted by the [recent] New York Times article about gentrification is the main problem is with the lack of ownership. Because without ownership you don’t have control. So a lot of people who own properties in the areas that are being gentrified may feel there is some cultural displacement taking place. But as owners, they can generally make a decision whether or not they’re going to sell and leave. When people don’t own a property, they’re renters and the owners decide to sell, then they’re out. So we need to focus on how we can increase homeownership. My wife and I bought our first home right when we were getting married in 1991. There was an old NCNB (a predecessor to Bank of America) an old NCNB program where we only had to come up with a $3,000 down payment. We were both young attorneys and we didn’t have $3,000 for that. We had to save for several months, each of us putting in a few hundred dollars until we got it and were able to buy our first home. We need to have more programs like that, like the one in East College Park that make homeownership more accessible for people who can afford to have a home but just may not have the money for a down payment or need other assistance. There’s not going to be one strategy that’s going to solve the whole problem. There needs to be a number of strategies. Up under the affordable housing problem is really a stagnation in the growth of wages. If people make enough money then they are able to afford housing but at the same time we’re trying to create more access to housing, we’ve got try and create and attract more jobs that pay a higher wage. If we do that, then more people will be able to afford the market rate for housing.
Raleigh’s Human Relations Commission recently recommended the city set up a police oversight board with investigative and subpoena powers. Raleigh’s Police Chief has stated she is not in favor of such a board. Does Raleigh need a board for police oversight?
The police have an incredibly difficult job. They are called in to some of the most violent, difficult, fraught, tense situations in human life and police need to be strongly supported by the city and its citizens. We need to pay officers well, perhaps more than what they are paid now. There is also an issue with force strength. A lot of people have told me as Raleigh has grown, the number of officers has not kept up with that and so they may be being spread too thin. So we need to look at whether we have enough officers for the job they’re being asked to do. But once we respect them as professionals and respect them in their compensation and the way we staff, then the citizens are entitled to a certain level of transparency back. We should have a body camera policy where those cameras are on all the time that they’re interacting with citizens. And some form of police oversight is necessary. I’m not sure about the exact form of it and whether it will go all the way to subpoena powers and things like that but something to increase transparency. We also should look at the training that officers are receiving to deal with people who have mental health issues, with LGBTQ people, and maybe what is needed is to have non-law enforcement people who are available to deal with some of these mental health situations so they can work to de-escalate a situation rather than have it escalating into violence. If there is a citizen review task force, I would require that the people who are on it undergo extensive training. If you’re a lawyer and you sign up to be an arbitrator, you have to take a 40 hour course, you have to really want to do it. There should be something like that for this, so that only people who are really serious about the problem will be a part of it and they’ll understand that most of the time, what the officers experience is mundane and it’s only the rare experience where you have something go sideways and there’s an allegation of excessive force. That’s not the norm and anyone who serves on this task force needs to understand something about what the daily realities of an officer are. And then they will be better able to assess that rare instance where something jumps off or goes sideways and there’s a claim of excessive force.
John Kane has proposed building a 40 story tower in the Peace Street area downtown. If elected Mayor, would you support the rezoning for that proposal as is, or try to negotiate for inclusion of affordable hosing units?
I haven’t studied that particular proposal in detail and I wouldn’t take a position on a proposal like that. In general, the downtown area where that property is should have more density. I don’t know what the exact level of stories needs to be without studying it further but, like I said before, we don’t want just density downtown for density’s sake but we want to have density with diversity, density with ethics and inclusion. You can’t expect the developer to pay the cost of affordable housing. There is a difference between the rent that is generated by market housing and affordable housing. It’s a social problem, so society has to contribute to the cost of funding it. That’s the reason why I proposed that task force, to try to figure out ways that we can fund that. I have some ideas on that. Project based vouchers may be helpful, using the bond money we’re talking about from past or future bonds to offset the difference could be helpful. I’m sure there are other strategies that could be used that I haven’t thought about, that smart people could come up with, but it just takes leadership to coordinate people and focus on solving that. In general, when you have a large, dense building built like that, you ought to do everything you can to include some affordable housing in the project. Developers are open to that, it’s just a question of how we’re going to pay for it.
Does Raleigh have enough density and do we currently have the infrastructure to support more?
There should be greater density in downtown. Ideally what you might have is sort of a wedding cake approach, where the tallest buildings are on Fayetteville Street and stepping down from 40 stories on Fayetteville Street to 20 to 15 as you go onto streets off of that. We should have more density downtown, but no, we don’t have the infrastructure to support it. So in building tall buildings and building greater density, we are going to have to improve the infrastructure.
CACs (neighborhood meetings) have traditionally been ways for citizens to engage with decisions that will go before the City Council. Do you support CACs or do you think, with a lot of these conversations happening online these days, that CACs have outlasted their usefulness?
There is still a role for CACs. They have been effective and I support them. The CAC system has been in place for a long time and I don’t think it has deterred growth in Raleigh at all. We need to look at ways to improve and increase citizen engagement and not try to limit citizen engagement. One of the reasons people all over Raleigh are frustrated is because they don’t think their voices are respected and heard. The CACs are one vehicle for that. We should look at people being able to participate online or by conference call. That’s a way that a lot of people participate and do business now. I suppose that there could be a, just like some people listen to a streaming church service, instead of actually being in the sanctuary we probably should look at technology where people could participate, or at least listen to, the CAC meeting online as well as being there. They wouldn’t take the place of an in-person meeting. There have been efforts by some staff and the city to limit the CACs and I would strongly oppose that. I support the CAC process.
Are the current members of the City Council putting forward a strong enough vision for Raleigh’s growth?
The current Council needs and requires and wants leadership. Why people are frustrated now, when they look at the Council, is they feel like there is a lack of leadership and lack of a leader. That’s what’s needed right now, leadership in the sense of someone who can get us to define what there is a consensus about. Not the lowest common denominator, but to set the consensus, being bold and something that’s conclusive that’s going to move us forward and then to bring a majority of the Council and a majority of the city together behind that vision to get it done. Mayor Meeker was very good at that when he was in office and that is what we need again, now. I have relationships with some of the members of Council now. The basis of any working relationship is personal relationships. I have good relationships with some of the members of the Council now and i am confident I can form good relationships with whoever is elected to the Council. There are a lot of talented people running, a lot of energy is behind those candidates and I look forward to working with whoever may be elected.
Are the city managers and staff doing a good job implementing the Council’s vision as stated and running the day to day operations of the city?
On the first question I need to learn more about that but I will defer until I learn more and answer the second. There have been instances where the Council defers too much to the staff and the Council cedes too much policy making authority to the staff. The job of the staff should be to execute and implement the policy adopted by the council and to advise the City Council on alternative courses of action, not to make policy themselves. Part of it is this council-manager form of governor that we have and this part-time City Council, it’s just easier to go along with the staff recommendation. I intend to go against the grain on that or push back on that because there have been too many instances where the staff has been allowed to make policy. A couple examples:
The site plan review process for certain types of site plans, bigger site plans, used to go to the Planning Commission and then the City Council. Now, a lot of it is just administered by the staff. When that change was made, people thought it would be a more streamlining change but it has not been because it results in just these endless rounds of reviews and comments by staff and a feeling by the citizens that they’re not getting a chance to be heard in a public forum. The site plan review process, certain big site plans, ought to go back to the Planning Commission and then to the Council and not just be a staff function.
A second example: there was recently a kerfuffle about Councilman Cox and his interceding on behalf of neighbors in Brentwood on a utility pipe going through their backyard. The essence of it was a utility pipe would be run, the city had chosen a course that was going to be vey disruptive to these Brentwood residents by going through their backyard, it was going to impact property values, affect their quality of life and that had been a staff decision. Councilman Cox spoke up against that decision and said “we should consider a parallel course that will have much less impact on these property owners.” Some people criticized him for doing that but I think it was entirely right and proper that he did that because something like that really was a policy decision that should not have been delegated to staff without any oversight or question. There needs to be a clear delineation in the way that things are run between policy and implementation and that the policy should fall to the Council even if that requires a little bit more work on the Council’s part.
Recently, the Council passed a suite of rules regulating Airbnb and electric scooters. Do you support the rules or feel they are too strict?
My position on scooters is that I am pro-scooter and pro micro-mobility. We ought to have a set of rules that makes it easier and not harder for young people and all people to be able to rent a scooter. On Airbnb, we need to revisit what we are doing with that. Airbnb and those types of home sharing arrangements are ways many people like to travel and ways people are able to achieve some additional income. So I think that needs to be revisited. Scooters need to be revisited too, in order to make sure we are not over-regulating the use of scooters and regulating them out of existence. The policy ought to lean toward making it easier instead of harder for people to rent scooters. Micro-mobility is good.
Last Word
I am a pro-development candidate and I will be a pro-development mayor. But—this is the big but—the growth that we have in the city shouldn’t be just for buildings or for the city limits. The growth should be for the benefit of the people who live here. The frustration many people have in Raleigh is that the growth has been exclusive and not inclusive. It has excluded people from neighborhoods and they have been here for a long time. It’s excluded them from gleaming towers downtown. We need to figure out a way that the city policy can help more people to be included in the growth and in the good life in Raleigh. So, I am pro growth, but a form of growth that more people who are already here now can benefit from. That’s what I’m looking forward to working with the City Council, the staff, the citizens on, coming up with that type of a model for growth, that type of model that would be more sustainable. One that includes more people, one that is environmentally friendly, one that considers more transit options. That is the type of growth we will be able to continue for decades and that people would truly benefit from.
by Jane Porter | Jun 25, 2019 | City Council
The City Council has proposed putting an affordable housing bond on the ballot next year. Do you support the bond and do you think that’s enough to address Raleigh’s affordable housing problem?
I do support the bond proposal, it;s a solution to a problem that we are years and decades behind on so we need to take action now. But having bonds every single time we need money for affordable housing is not the answer. By keeping bonds just focused on affordable housing, we take away the aspect of looking at it holistically. Like how are we doing affordable housing with transit, how we are making it sustainable, how are we making the quality of life better for our residents? The bonds make us evaluate our success based off how many houses are built versus how many homes are created, how many people we’ve made better quality of life for. So there are other ways the Council can be looking at addressing housing. We’ve seen things like getting rid of single-family zoning work around different places in the country. We know that comes from the Jim Crowe era and causes inequities that we, as a city, know we can do better on. I got my Masters in Public Administration and I learned about zoning, specifically around [eliminating] single family zoning; that has shown the biggest impact you can have and a very small risk pool. We also need to make sure we are involving the most impacted people in the conversation first, that we are going out and listening to the community and figuring out what can we do to not only build affordable housing but to convert renters to owners, how to go into the community and fix up the houses already there, how do we let people who have been part of these communities forever stay in there and embrace development that reinvests in their own community? i don’t think development and growth is wrong but it is wrong when you’re only developing in areas now because that land is valuable, land that was never valuable before, but now is and you’re pushing people out from there.
Raleigh’s Human Relations Commission recently recommended the city set up a police oversight board with investigative and subpoena powers. Raleigh’s Police Chief has stated she is not in favor of such a board. Does Raleigh need a board for police oversight?
Raleigh needs accountability. Because this is portrayed so highly in national media, we stay away from it here, but us wanting feedback or to improve our police force does not mean we’re against the police force. Everyone respects and honors what our officers do every single day but we also recognize there is no way to do our job better unless we get better. There is no other job in the country that you’re going to be able to move to the next level, you’re going to be able to improve in your career, unless you go through more training, unless you get more resources to help you get to that level. The fact that people want that and want it because we also know it will impact the residents that our officers are serving, is the basic right of a community. The reason people want a police accountability board is not because everyone wants to oversee and micro-manage the police. They don’t trust in the government right now to do that job. So once you build that trust with the residents and you get residents to trust the government, there won’t be a need to push and fight for police accountability anymore because our leaders will be holding people accountable. So people don’t have to be there pushing for that. Unfortunately, trust is not there for all residents and we’ve got to recognize that. It might be there for some residents but at the end of the day, statistics show that these issues exist, especially in low-income and black and brown communities.
John Kane has proposed building a 40 story tower in the Peace Street area downtown. If elected Mayor, would you support the rezoning for that proposal as is, or try to negotiate for inclusion of affordable hosing units?
If you’re going to build a 40 story tower, there better be some affordable housing in there. It just seems simple. It’s pretty clear that developers are also interested in the idea and in providing affordable housing, but would still be allowed to build more dense buildings. What a great tradeoff. Why are we not thinking about that when we are letting developers propose these buildings? We should actively be thinking about that. It takes a leader and a vision and wanting to work in partnerships and some creativity, understanding that the public and private worlds can work together, provide social good and do it with more urgency because we can build a lot more housing than we are building now. What we do now is we go and look at a city—say Seattle—and we continue to look at that city. What we need to do is to look at a lot of cities and, second, recognize whatever model we use here in Raleigh is not going to look like what every other city looks like. We need to create a model that is specific to the city, the needs, the history of the city. I don’t have a silver bullet of what’s going to work whats not and I don’t think any city in the world has figured it out. But what’s cool about it is we have the timing and the people and the resources that can study everybody and figure out a very comprehensive solution that specifically fits the community we have right now.
Does Raleigh have enough density and do we currently have the infrastructure to support more?
I don’t think we are dense enough. There is not a way for us to build out anymore, we need to build up. We do have the infrastructure to support it but at end of the day, it’s about the fact that we need more units, we need more places for people to live and no way you can do that without density, no way you’re going to do that without getting rid of single-family zoning. And we cant be for affordable housing and make the city more transit oriented without increasing density. It is just not possible, it is not possible for any city we’ve seen anywhere in the country. So we’ve really got to embrace that and understand that that doesn’t mean we’re going to start building 40 story complexes in the middle of a neighborhood in Brier Creek. That’s not what that means. It means we can build some taller buildings in downtown and also build a few stories in other places so it doesn’t all just look the same. That also means hey, you may get a grocery store walking distance to where you live now, maybe then you’ll get a transit line on there because there are mixed use areas and businesses. So it opens people up to opportunities.
CACs (neighborhood meetings) have traditionally been ways for citizens to engage with decisions that will go before the City Council. Do you support CACs or do you think, with a lot of these conversations happening online these days, that CACs have outlasted their usefulness?
There is space for them. How we get citizen engagement and how citizens are engaged in the city does need to be re-looked at. If CACs provide an avenue for people, specifically people who have always been involved in politics, maybe from a different generation than I am, that is completely fine. You keep what you know and you make it better. But there definitely need to be more ways for people to get involved than just attending a meeting at 7 p.m. or trying to go to Council at 1 p.m. while everyone is working. I don’t know if this is the most efficient way to engage citizens but I do know people hold true to the CACs and it is part of a rich history of how work has gotten done in the city. If people are engaged that way, it is one tool we have. It is not our all-go-to tool for citizen engagement. We should have multiple tools in our toolbox making sure we’re getting citizens engaged because you have to engage people in various ways because not everyone is able to engage in the same way to go to those meetings.
Are the current members of the City Council putting forward a strong enough vision for Raleigh’s growth?
Right now, we are building a city for 2020, not 2050. We have a lot of varying issues under our belt the current City Council has tried to solve, tried different methods, tried to put effort into fixing, but at the end of the day, these are problems every city across the country is facing, if not the world. That means you need new leaders, new visions, new people in there that have not traditionally been in those spaces because you need new ideas to fix these problems. So Council needs leadership and vision, specifically vision in a city that’s the second biggest tech hub after Silicon Valley. We are in a prime place to where if we got more visionaries into office, we’d have all the resources and the people to make such an impact in a very fast-paced way that most cities won’t have the opportunity to.
Are the city managers and staff doing a good job implementing the Council’s vision as stated and running the day to day operations of the city?
I can’t completely speak to that, you really have to be working in City Council to know. But honestly, from what I have sensed from events and when I have interacted with staff, we have amazing staff. We have recruited people from all around the country, we have people onboard who have been in Raleigh forever, making amazing programs. I really do think leadership comes from the top. The people are amazing, they have the resources, they have the creativity, they want to do more. The thing that holds them up is Council
Recently, the Council passed a suite of rules regulating Airbnb and electric scooters. Do you support the rules or feel they are too strict?
The Airbnb rule goes into effect in 2020 so I’m hoping when I’m elected, we can switch that real fast. I don’t agree wth either of them. There are ways to build partnerships with people, work with them and compromise. For us, it is just “no, there is no other answer.” There’s no trying to figure out “Alright, there are a good amount of people valuing, making income off of Airbnb, or off charging the Bird scooters.” That conversation has been completely left out, the fact that this is a second paycheck for people, especially for the Bird scooters. People—kids and teens—were making a living off of it and it was a good idea in a place that doesn’t have high chance of upward mobility. On top of that, you make things more expensive. When people visit from out of town, our hotels are very expensive and limited. Airbnb was an option for people to stay in at an affordable price. It was a place for families to stay in and not be forced to get three hotel rooms because they have a big family. When we did Airbnb, we based it off Asheville. We are different from Asheville, we’re not a tourist attraction. We are a place people come for work, to visit, to just enjoy and they should be able to enjoy it in a neighborhood, to really see the history of Raleigh. Where better to do that than in an Airbnb? With the scooters, what’s interesting is now Council has a contract and they’re going to have it with a new scooter company. The difference with that company is you can’t make income off of it. So the company would have to charge the scooters. Basically what they did was got rid of the Bird scooters and then said “We will bring this other company back but you can’t make any money off of it.” Now who is really getting harmed in that picture? Who are we benefitting and who are we harming? We also failed to talk about the environment in this conversation, the fact we are a car city—every day we add 63 people to Wake County, so that means we add just as many cars. Bird scooters take away that carbon. We didn’t think about, not only does it access mobility but we’re in a time where climate change is a very pressing need and Raleigh needs to be thinking about that in every single decision we make.
Last Word
In my 28 years in Raleigh, I have met a lot of talented, good people and I really think that the people here in Raleigh are ready to lead Raleigh into the future. But they need people in office who are equitable, they need to be equitably represented, need people who have a vision in mind and are truly part of the community and know Raleigh and can really speak out for others. My platform is focused on mobility, security and happiness and the idea that everyone in the city should have economic opportunities to thrive and do better, to have security and feel safe in their neighborhoods and to feel protected by protectors, to not feel like police might be working with ICE. And then happiness. A lot of countries will gage their communities’ happiness. I read an article recently that stated that America is increasing in happiness inequality. The idea is to have basic shelter, to be able to trust your energy providers, to know the water you’re drinking is clean, to know your government has your well-being at heart and will remove barriers that keep you from pursuing a higher quality of life.
by Jane Porter | Jun 25, 2019 | Buzz, City Council, July/August 2019, Top Reads
This story has been updated to include answers from mayoral candidates George Knott and Justin Sutton. Follow the links below for the full interviews with Knott and Sutton and check back for interviews with other mayoral candidates who file before the July 19 deadline.
Filing for Raleigh’s October 8 municipal elections opens this month and six candidates so far have filed to run for mayor. Former City Council member Mary-Ann Baldwin, community organizer and state worker Zainab Baloch, attorney Charles Francis, former County Commissioner Caroline Sullivan, musician George Knott and attorney Justin Sutton share their thoughts on affordable housing, police accountability, managing growth and the City Council’s long term vision.
Follow the links for the full interviews with Baldwin, Baloch, Francis, Sullivan, Sutton and Knott.
Affordable Housing
Baldwin: “We need policy changes, planning and leadership. We have to stop treating developers like the enemy and figure out incentives and how we can work in partnership with them.”
We asked if candidates support the City Council’s proposal to put an affordable housing bond on the ballot next year. They do, but say more is needed.
Supports ADUs (aka backyard cottages or granny flats), cottage courts and tiny homes; reducing minimum lot sizes and parking requirements, using publicly owned excess property for housing, building along transit corridors, partnering with developers for land swaps and eliminating single family zoning (city laws dictating building only homes designed for a single family).
Baloch: “We need to make sure we’re involving the most impacted people in the conversation first. We need to listen and figure out how to build more affordable housing, convert renters to owners, fix up housing we already have, let people who have been in their communities stay and embrace development that reinvests in the community.”
Supports building along transit corridors, eliminating single family zoning.
Francis: “We need to immediately set up a task force of developers interested in building affordable housing, bankers, bond attorneys, tax attorneys, activists, and come up with five to 10 things, right away, that will have immediate impact.”
Supports using bond money to subsidize developers to include affordable units, focusing on increasing homeownership, and programs where buyers who can afford to own, for instance, get assistance saving up for a down payment. Proposes expanding tax credits for developments that increase density in areas where forecasted—“but it needs to be density with diversity, not just for high-income people.” Proposes changing the city’s site plan review process for larger projects; instead of city staff reviewing site plans, reviews should go directly to the city’s Planning Commission and then to the City Council for public input.
Sullivan: “You’ve got traditional affordable housing, voucher programs, Section 8, city housing; supportive housing for individuals with mental health and substance abuse disorders; veteran housing; workforce housing; housing for young people just starting out; senior housing. Different groups of people need safe, affordable housing and you’ve got different funding and capital streams for them. We have to figure out how best to coordinate and deploy all of those strategies.”
Supports convening a stakeholder group to develop strategies to address affordable housing. Says partnering with private developers and nonprofits to build new stock, continuing programs to help keep people in their homes, mortgage assistance and assistance for first-time buyers will be key.
Knott: Supports incentivizing/requiring developers to include affordable housing units in new projects. (Currently, state law prohibits municipalities from requiring developers to include affordable housing). Supports adding affordable housing downtown through zoning/permitting initiatives.
“A bond is what you do when you have a onetime project that requires capital and the way our city is working and runs now, we absolutely need to do that. But a better answer would be, let’s not make affordable housing a bond issue. Let’s roll it into the budget and fund it every single budget year and we should have been doing that for the last 20 years.”
Sutton: “With any proposed affordable housing development, we need to ensure access to public services, education, healthcare facilities, recreational resources, transportation, and job opportunities.”
Says a bond referendum on affordable housing is not a sustainable model for residents. Supports expanding existing housing programs, rental vouchers, subsidies, housing rehabilitation and Council allocating more funding to homebuyer assistance programs for first time low-income buyers.
Police Accountability
We asked if candidates support a police oversight board with investigative and subpoena powers (it would need authorization from state lawmakers).
Baldwin: “We need to do a better job of communicating with all different groups within the city. Community policing is really important so people can get to know each other and work together to do good.”
Does not support petitioning the General Assembly to set up a board with subpoena powers.
Baloch: “People want a police accountability board not because they want to micromanage the police; they don’t trust the government to do that job. Once you build that trust with all residents, there won’t be a need to fight for police accountability anymore. Unfortunately, that trust is not there for all residents and we’ve got to recognize that.”
Francis: Supports looking at paying officers more; expanding the number of officers on the police force to keep pace with growth; enacting an on-at-all-times body camera policy; expanding officer training in interactions with people with mental health issues.
“If there is a citizen review task force, the people on it need to undergo extensive training. They need to understand daily realities for officers, that it’s rare for something to go sideways and for there to be an allegation of excessive force.”
Sullivan: “There needs to be increased engagement and people need to feel heard. We have to look at safety in a bigger way. What can law enforcement do to engage communities? Police need to establish relationships before there are crises. And we need to continue intervention training for officers. Only 386 officers out of 800 have been trained in crisis intervention.”
Knott: Supports a police oversight board with subpoena power as a “first step to give citizens more accountability and transparency.”
“You can have an entire police force of, it doesn’t matter if they’re white or black police officers, if they have done all the racial training in the world, it’s not a white-black thing. It’s a police-citizen thing. The police are in power, they hold it over the poor people. And the problem is, until we figure out how to get around that, no police accountability board will ever work.”
Sutton: Supports a community oversight board “to foster strategic and collaborative partnerships between RPD and key neighborhood stakeholders.”
“We need increased community engagement to ensure our safety needs are being met along with programs that focus on public safety education. I also believe there is a need for criminal justice reform through comprehensive officer training programs. However, we are currently hampered by budget cuts which may delay implementation along with a backlog of public safety equipment needs.”
A 40 Story Building on Peace Street
Developer John Kane wants to rezone an area of Peace Street to build a 40 story tower. We asked candidates if they would support the proposal as is or negotiate for affordable housing.
Baldwin: “That’s my neighborhood and I would love to look out at that every day. [Neighbors] are supportive and have been waiting for development in this area of downtown for a long time. It is totally underutilized, underdeveloped and underresourced.”
Supports proposal because it is on a Bus Rapid Transit line and next to a cycle track; says city should be more creative with incentives rather than “beating developers over the head” with tradeoffs for affordable housing.
Baloch: “It’s pretty clear developers are interested in providing affordable housing and if they can still build dense buildings…what a great tradeoff.”
Francis: “In general, downtown should have more density. You can’t expect the developer to pay the cost of affordable housing—there’s a difference between the rent generated by market housing and affordable housing. It’s a social problem, so society has to contribute to the cost of funding it. Developers are open to [including affordable housing], it’s just a question of how we pay for it.”
Sullivan: “Density where it makes sense is needed. That’s a very dense part of downtown already. It is zoned to be dense and the improvements on Peace Street and Capital Boulevard will help that. It is becoming what we want in a dense neighborhood, walkable, with grocery stores.”
Knott: Says the tower is a bad idea due to infrastructure constraints but acknowledges that more housing is needed.
“There is a very real over-exertion of the infrastructure on the street all by itself. I’m not even talking about sewer or water. I believe we are in an enormous [real estate] bubble. And if it pops, it’s going to be really messy downtown. Like all these high-rises three quarters empty? Whoa, could you imagine.”
Sutton:Does not support proposal as is but would consider an “affordable housing cost share project” with willing developers and public input.
Density and Infrastructure
We asked if Raleigh is dense enough and if it has the infrastructure to support more density.
Baldwin: “We do have the infrastructure but the way to get more is to look at mobility choices. If people bike, walk or take the bus to work, it alleviates traffic and you need less parking. We don’t have enough density and the core is where density belongs.”
Baloch: “There is no way to build out anymore, we need to build up. We do have the infrastructure to support density but we need more units and more transit options. There’s no way you can do that without density.”
Francis: “There should be greater density downtown, ideally like a wedding cake approach where the tallest buildings are on Fayetteville Street and step down to 20, 15 stories as you go onto the streets off of that. We don’t have the infrastructure to support density, so in building taller buildings, we’re going to have to improve infrastructure.”
Sullivan: “There is not enough stock in general and infrastructure is going to continue to be a challenge. But we are going to have more robust transit options, which will help as we grow.”
Knott: Does not think Raleigh has the infrastructure to support more density.
“That’s my No. 1 biggest concern. We have an amazing infrastructure for a town that’s half our size.”
Sutton: “There are limitations to growth. Increased density will only strain our infrastructure and city resources (i.e. public utilities, public safety response, roadways, etc.)…If anything, we will need to place greater emphasis on city infrastructure and asset management programs to streamline business and public safety operations in the most densely populated areas of the city.”
Council’s Vision for Growth
We asked if current City Council members put forth a strong long-term vision for growth.
Baldwin: “They don’t have a vision. The vision is ‘We want things to stay the way they are.’ Raleigh is going to grow whether people like it or not and I don’t want to end up like Seattle with two-hour commutes, where the average price of a home is inching up to a million dollars.”
Baloch: “We’re building a city for 2020, not for 2050. We need new leaders, new visions, new people who have not traditionally been in those spaces with new ideas to fix problems. Raleigh is the biggest tech hub after Silicon Valley. We’re in a prime place where, with more visionaries, we have the resources and people to make an impact.”
Francis: “People are frustrated when they look at the Council now because they see a lack of leadership and lack of a leader. That’s what’s needed, someone who can define what there is consensus about, be bold and do something conclusive to move us forward. Mayor Meeker was good at that when he was in office and that’s what we need again.”
Sullivan: “There’s room for improvement. There need to be more discussions about growth in general, where we’ll be in five, 10, 20 years, how we manage growth and how, in the process, everyone’s voice is heard. I fear if we don’t make decisions on where we want to be in the future, it will be difficult to handle the growth as it comes.”
Knott:“They’re putting forward the wrong vision for Raleigh’s growth. I’m a proponent of organic growth, I’m not a proponent of artificially driven growth. We pay millions of dollars for economic development and we give tax credits where companies don’t pay taxes for years at a time. The ramifications of that are absolutely killing our city.”
Sutton:“Our needs are constantly changing…we will need to reassess the appropriateness of specific projects in order to allocate taxpayer dollars to the greatest areas of need… We need responsible and effective budgeting strategies to address the true long-term vision for Raleigh’s progressive growth.”
Management and Staffing
We asked if Raleigh’s city managers and staffers are doing a good job implementing the Council’s vision as stated and in running the city day to day.
Baldwin: “We have one of the best staffs in the country, really smart people working for us. A major problem is that the Council has engaged in a war with staff. Staffers are belittled, shamed and attacked. That is totally inappropriate behavior. The problem is the City Council is interfering in staff’s work. We need to look at our code of conduct and call people out or set up policies that say what isn’t allowed, to stop the bad behavior.”
Baloch: “From my sense of city events and interactions, we have an amazing staff. We’ve recruited people from all over the country and we have people onboard who have been in Raleigh forever, doing amazing programs. Leadership comes from the top. The people have the resources, the creativity, and they want to do more, but what holds them up is Council.”
Francis: “There have been instances where Council defers too much to the staff and cedes too much policy making authority. The job of the staff should be to execute and implement policy adopted by the Council, not make policy themselves. With the council-manager form of government we have and a part-time City Council, it can be easier to just go along with the staff recommendation. I intend to push back on that because there have been too many instances where staff has been allowed to make policy.”
Sullivan: “We have a strong city manager and the staff does a good job. It’s important for elected officials to be able to give staff a strong vision of where the city should be going, and guidance so they can execute what needs to be done every day. But there are a lot of talented people and they do a good job serving the community.”
Knott:“I have so much respect for the professionals, the staff and city manger, they’re professionals. And politicians are at best amateurs and at worst, politicians. I have the utmost respect for professionals, and that includes the staff of the city and the city planners.”
Sutton: “There must be a dynamic shift in how we do business in this city, how we govern as a collective body, and how we effectively manage city resources for long term sustainability and growth.”
Follow the links for the full interviews with Francis, Baloch, Sullivan, Knott, Sutton and Baldwin.
by Jane Porter | Mar 29, 2019 | April 2019, Buzz
She’s Running!
In the weeks since Mayor Nancy McFarlane announced she wouldn’t seek a fifth term—and Charles Francis, her 2017 opponent confirmed he would run for the top seat again this year—all eyes were on Mary Ann Baldwin. She didn’t disappoint.
The five-term Councilor stepped away from her at-large seat in 2017, citing a desire to make a difference outside the system and work to cultivate future leaders. But those close to her know that Baldwin has considered running for mayor in the past and also know that, at a time when the council is deeply divided on issues of growth, Baldwin feels a sense of urgency in repositioning the city on what she believes is the right path for its future. And for many of McFarlane’s (many) proponents, sad to see the mayor go, “the notorious MAB” looks like a good replacement.
Baldwin, the executive director for the Holt Brothers Foundation, is unapologetically pro-development in contrast to members of the current council majority who favor “slow” or “smart” growth. Baldwin has been at odds with recent council decisions and non-decisions, including its reluctance to move on allowing accessory dwelling units, its seeming wariness of allowing for density and its perceived over-regulation of new industries and technology, including short term rentals like Airbnb and electric scooters. Baldwin will likely align herself with a group of young, progressive candidates running for district and at large seats who share her frustrations with the current council—a smart strategy as the city’s population, and voting majority, is skewing ever younger and more diverse.
But there are those who feel the council is in need of a “reset” and—given Baldwin’s past council experience and less than warm relationships with some current members who could hang on to their seats this fall—make the argument that the city needs someone new at its helm.
It’s a matter of game theory. Baldwin knows she has a lot of support in Raleigh but her path to the mayor’s seat won’t be easy, or pretty. She has thick skin but this municipal election likely won’t look like anything Raleigh’s seen for a while. “Safe” seats will be credibly contested. Mud will be slung. The one certainty is that, come 2020, the city will have a new mayor in place.
Let the games begin.
We’re very far away from knowing who Raleigh’s next mayor will be but that’s never stopped us from speculating before! With three confirmed candidates and a bunch of would-be candidates on the record as not running, the field is still wide open in this horse race. Here are the jockeys whose names have been thrown around and their odds based on what we know so far. The frontrunners are clear, the dark horses here for a reason. The best way for your horse to win? Take it to the polls in October.
Charles Francis 3/2
Francis, an attorney, announced first and therefore starts out head and shoulders above everyone else. His message of change and platform focused on aggressively addressing the city’s systemic problems brought him within about 6,000 votes against McFarlane in 2017 (though he lost by a wider margin in the runoff). We’re willing to bet Francis will hang on to most of his supporters from last time. Plus, there’s no popular Mayor McFarlane to contend with this year…
Mary Ann Baldwin 2/1
Which brings us to MAB. Like the mayor, Baldwin has her share of ardent supporters who could tip a race in her favor and her platform aligns with McFarlane’s. If it comes down to Baldwin vs. Francis, it will hinge on what kind of change voters want: if they want the city to go in a whole new direction, they’ll vote for Francis. If they want a more forceful version of McFarlane, they’ll vote for Baldwin. What if they’re happy with the way things are going but want to see a council reset?
Caroline Sullivan 3/1
Then, they’ll vote for Caroline Sullivan. Said to be McFarlane’s pick, the former Wake Commissioner was drawn out of her district in 2016 and now works in Gov. Cooper’s office. She would bring a fresh but still progressive perspective, relevant experience and the distance needed to help minimize the infighting that has hamstrung the council recently. How will the race between Sullivan and Baldwin shake out? How will their supporters split? And where will that leave Francis?
Sig Hutchinson 8/1
He hasn’t said no, and he may feel he can effect more change in key areas like parks and affordable housing as mayor rather than as a Wake Commissioner. But Hutchinson won re-election in the fall and the timing just doesn’t seem right somehow. Maybe we’ll see him run for mayor in 2021?
Bonner Gaylord 12/1
Before losing his District E seat to Stef Mendell in 2017, many believed Bonner Gaylord would succeed McFarlane. But since he’s been off the council, the North Hills operations director has shown little interest in returning. Though well-funded and well connected, few think Gaylord has the appetite to return to a council that could continue to be bitterly divided. Honestly, who can blame him?
Paul Fitts 16/1
Paul Fitts here is actually just a stand-in for whichever Republican the local GOP persuades to run in the ostensibly nonpartisan race—because, well, there’s always someone. Your run-of-the-mill Raleigh voter cares more about transit and affordable housing over curbing city spending these days, so Fitts, or whoever the candidate will be, is very much the underdog. But, as we all know, crazier things have happened.
A different version of this story appears in Raleigh Magazine’s April issue. It has been updated online to reflect recent campaign announcements.