Red Hat Amphitheater Is Still at Risk

Red Hat Amphitheater Is Still at Risk

Thanks to a twist in proceedings, Red Hat Amp could still be demolished. 

ICYMI, Red Hat Amphitheater is still at risk of being lost, due to a rare (and unfortunate) twist in City Council proceedings. 

The South Street plan is now slated to be voted on a second—and hopefully final—time Oct. 15, with the same consequences as before if the vote fails (bye-bye, Red Hat Amp). So, if you’re wondering how this happened—after weeks of advocating for the amphitheater and celebrating an apparent victory—we break it down for you. 

There are two parts in the process—approving the street closure and amending the Comprehensive Plan to remove this block as a street. On Sept. 17, City Council voted unanimously (with two absences) to close a block of South Street to make room for the Red Hat Amphitheater expansion. Afterward, on Sept. 24, the Planning Commission (an appointed body, not elected) voted to deny the Comprehensive Plan component.

This vote is only a recommendation to City Council, and council members are not required to accept their decision. And, so, on Oct. 15, the Comprehensive Plan amendment will head back to council for approval, without the recommendation of the Planning Commission. 

As a result, like before, if this City Council vote does not pass, the Red Hat Amphitheater expansion project is dead, meaning the amphitheater would be demolished for good and Live Nation is likely to take their booking outside of Raleigh. 

So, what can you do to support the amphitheater and help (finally) put the issue to rest? Show up at the Oct. 15 City Council meeting wearing red. A large in-person presence will show Raleigh is still paying attention—and isn’t going to let this issue fly under the radar. Once again, let’s band together to save Red Hat Amphitheater.

Red Hat Amphitheater Set to Remain Downtown

Red Hat Amphitheater Set to Remain Downtown

City Council votes to save Red Hat Amphitheater.

Red Hat Amphitheater lives on! (Pause for applause and happy tears.) Raleigh City Council voted unanimously (with exception of the absent Mary Black of District A and Christina Jones of District E) to expand and update the popular DTR concert venue—and close the one highly debated block of South Street necessary to prevent Red Hat Amp from shuttering permanently.

The planned expansion will accommodate ~1,000 more seats and a larger loading dock and backstage area, as well as increased concessions, with the project slated for a late Q1 2025 groundbreaking and a reopening in 2026—just in time for outdoor concert season (!). 

That said, expansion will have its obstacles, as pointed out by concerned residents of the surrounding neighborhoods. The city is working with NCDOT to offset the closure of the block of South Street—also slated for Q1 2025—with a yet-to-be-approved slip lane connecting Dawson and McDowell streets, which is estimated to cost $2–3 million. 

“The money is there, but we need to figure out what pocket to take it from, such as Capital Reserves,” says Jonathan Melton, member at-large. “My primary goal here is to maintain as much connectivity for South Street as possible. And I think that connector will help with that, and also, to improve the condition for bicycles, pedestrians, wheelchairs, scooters and strollers in that area.” Melton, as well as council member Corey Branch of District C, also suggested incorporating some sort of significant nod to the history of the Fourth Ward.

Despite the remaining details , the health and future of Downtown has been saved, with Red Hat Amp and all its economic impact ($17.5 mil in 2023!) staying put in our city’s center to benefit surrounding small businesses, restaurants, bars and breweries—not to mention Raleighites near and far. Let the music play on!  

Do City Council Candidates Stand With Red Hat Amp?

Do City Council Candidates Stand With Red Hat Amp?

We asked all sitting members of Raleigh City Council—and other candidates vying for a seat—whether they stand with the expansion of Red Hat Amp.

With the vote deciding Red Hat Amphitheater’s fate in less than a month, we tapped Raleigh City Council candidates—plus the sitting Council members who are all up for reelection—on whether they think the venue should remain Downtown or be moved elsewhere (for example, Dix Park). 

Although only the current council members will have any say in the vote, other candidates’ take on the amphitheater’s location can give insight on their knowledge of Raleigh and priorities within the city. And, ICYMI, Red Hat Amp cannot be left where it is—it must be either moved one block and expanded or demolished for good. 

Mayoral Candidates

Janet Cowell
Red Hat [Amp] should stay Downtown. It helps make Downtown a regional destination for arts and culture and supports local businesses at a time when they urgently need it. In exchange for the negative externalities of closing a street, we should preserve pedestrian, bicycle and vehicular throughways while mitigating the impact of street closure on Heritage Park and insulating residents from service loading docks.

Paul Fitts 
Leave it where it is.

Eugene Myrick  
I am not in favor of moving Red Hat Amphitheater to Dix Park. While the amphitheater is a beloved venue, relocating it would have significant and far-reaching consequences that outweigh the potential benefits. Moving the amphitheater would negatively impact local businesses that have long benefited from its Downtown location. The foot traffic and economic activity generated by events at Red Hat Amphitheater support our small businesses, which are the backbone of our local economy. Disrupting this ecosystem could lead to closures and lost livelihoods for many who rely on this steady stream of patrons.

Terrance Ruth
The location of Red Hat Amphitheater should be determined by what best serves the community’s needs and enhances the cultural vibrancy of Raleigh. Keeping it Downtown supports local businesses and maintains the city’s cultural hub. However, moving it to Dix Park could offer unique opportunities, but the fragile nature of our Downtown requires the city’s full attention. I would advocate for extensive community input before making a decision.

James Shaughnessy IV
I am in favor of keeping Red Hat Amphitheater Downtown. It’s become a cultural staple in the area and plays a vital role in supporting local businesses by driving foot traffic and generating economic activity. Its presence Downtown is beneficial both for the economy and the cultural vibrancy of the city.

At-large Candidates

James Bledsoe
No. Red Hat [Amp] needs to stay where it is. Moving a large property like that to expand a Convention Center that isn’t full when events are held is just asking to hurt Downtown. Many businesses rely on foot traffic from the events. Moving Red Hat [Amp] during an already financially stressed Downtown Raleigh is just going to break a lot of businesses’ backs.

Joshua Bradley 
I am of the opinion that it can stay where it is. The Convention Center does not need to expand. The planned move would close South Street and negatively impact Heritage Park, which is one of the few public housing complexes in the City.

Stormie Forte (I)
Yes, I am in favor of the Red Hat Amphitheater expansion, while understanding the concerns regarding a closure of a small portion of [South Street]. Within the budget allocated for the project, the current plan is the only option available to keep the amphitheater Downtown. The City of Raleigh staff are working with the NC Department of Transportation to create a solution that will allow continued connectivity to the Downtown area from South Street. I have had the opportunity to speak with many owners of local small businesses regarding the negative economic impact of losing the amphitheater Downtown. I want to support initiatives that will help these establishments not only survive, but thrive. Red Hat Amphitheater has over 50 shows scheduled this season and eight weeks for the ice rink. Many Raleigh residents and guests from out of town enjoy coming Downtown for these events, and contribute significantly to the viability of surrounding businesses. It is important for the owners and their employees that these opportunities continue to create foot traffic in these spaces. 

Jonathan Melton (I)
Yes, and I want the city to work with NCDOT on reestablishing some connection for the portion of South Street that is closed, and to add bicycle and pedestrian improvements too. This project can be a win-win for all interested stakeholders.  

Reeves Peeler 
I want to see the amphitheater stay Downtown.

Robert Steele 
I am in favor of the Red Hat Amphitheater staying Downtown.

District A Candidates

Mary Black (I)
Neutral. I think the role of councilors is to weigh the multiple factors within in any case. I’m eager to hear from the city about the multiple factors that are at play with regard to impact to traffic, Heritage Park redevelopment and businesses. 

Whitney Hill 
I am in favor of seeing Red Hat [Amp] staying where it is and keeping Dawson Street a straight shot through Downtown. No one has shown me the cost profit analysis of doubling the size of the Civic Center. If they have [it], I would love to see it. To me, this is the real issue. Are the citizens at large really benefiting from the Civic Center Expansion?

Mitchell Silver
I am in favor of keeping Red Hat Amphitheater Downtown and would encourage City Council to explore and make public all available options, including those that keep South Street open. 

District B Candidates

Jennifer McCollum
Yes, I am in favor of Red Hat Amphitheater staying Downtown.

Megan Patton (I)
With roughly a month until the vote regarding the street closure, I am still in the information-gathering phase. This decision impacts several constituencies in a variety of ways. From Heritage Park to Downtown businesses, from Boylan Heights to the larger Raleigh community, I’m committed to hearing all the voices. No decision that the Council faces is ever as simple as it seems. I’m working hard to make sure we get as many wins for as many stakeholders as possible.

District C Candidates

Corey Branch (I)
I’m in favor of keeping Red Hat Amphitheater Downtown. 

DaQuanta Copeland
Yes, I support the Red Hat Amphitheater staying Downtown. 

Tomara DeCosta
It should remain Downtown, as local businesses depend on the foot traffic it generates. 

Daniel Grant-King
No response as of press time. 

Jared Ollison 
If Red Hat is to be expanded, I think it would be a good idea to consider moving it to Dix Park. 

Tolulope Omokaiye
I am in favor of the Red Hat Amphitheater remaining Downtown. 

Portia Rochelle
In favor of [Red Hat Amp] staying Downtown

District D Candidates

Jane Harrison (I)
I’m committed to Red Hat Amphitheater remaining Downtown and anticipate it to be moved one block south to make room for the Convention Center expansion. It has significant economic spillover impacts on local businesses like Berkeley Cafe, Videri Chocolate Factory, and Neptunes, just to name a few. It’s a beloved community asset—essential for vibrancy and safety Downtown.

Residents and business owners also have legitimate concerns about the loss of vehicular access on South Street. Unfortunately, closing the street is a prerequisite to expansion of the Convention Center and the Red Hat [Amp] relocation. I’ve spent a great deal of time with city staff and impacted neighbors to examine the plans and identify opportunities to mitigate potential negative impacts. City staff is working with the NC Department of Transportation to develop a new route which would connect just south of South Street heading west to east. The City is also conducting a traffic-impact analysis to evaluate impacts. An additional community engagement opportunity will be held prior to any City Council decision.

District E Candidates

John Cerqueira
Red Hat should absolutely stay Downtown at a scale that continues attracting the types of shows we have been fortunate to host in the past. I do look forward to the potential of a music venue at Dix Park at what is planned to be a scale closer to what we have at the NC Museum of Art. 

Christina Jones (I)
No response as of press time. 

Red Hat Amphitheater Is Still at Risk

11 Things to Know About the Proposed Red Hat Amphitheater

We tap Raleigh Convention Center’s executive director Kerry Painter for answers to lingering questions surrounding Red Hat Amp’s proposed expansion.

ICYMI, the future of Red Hat Amphitheater is at stake. 

While it was initially intended to be a temporary venue, the City has long planned to move and update the amphitheater to sustain the amount of traffic it attracts. The planned expansion would accommodate ~1,000 more seats and a larger loading dock and backstage area, as well as increased concessions—and the only “cost” of that expansion is the closure of one block of South Street, a road that sees just one-third of the traffic it was built for.

As the Sept. 17 City Council vote grows closer, confusion surrounding what will actually happen to the amphitheater mounts—as well as rumors about why different infrastructure decisions were made. 

Here, we cut to the chase, tapping Raleigh Convention Center and Performing Arts Complex Executive Director Kerry Painter —who has also run venues in Tulsa, Ontario, Niagara Falls and Slidell—to clear the air on lingering questions. 

What happens to Red Hat Amp if they do not vote to pass the South Street closure?   

We cannot build the amphitheater and it will likely be lost. 

What will happen if the vote is tied?

If the vote is tied, then the motion fails. The project does not have support to advance, and we lose the amp. 

If the closure does not pass, is there an alternative plan in the works to save the amphitheater and keep music Downtown?

No. There is no other Downtown location available to us that meets the requirements for a viable venue within our given budget. 

When and why did the proposed street closure switch from Lenoir Street to South Street? 

The amphitheater and what it needs to be viable does not fit on Lenoir and the lot of land we own. It left us with approximately 4,500 seats instead of the 6,000 minimum and was over budget. It didn’t provide the operational needs and safety needs as well as artist spaces necessary. By incorporating South Street, we also have the ability to tap into another plot of land owned by NCDOT, which then makes enough space for the new design and its needs.

How much traffic is there on South Street compared to Lenoir? 

South Street sees approximately 3,300 cars a day, and Lenoir Street [sees] 2,250. These streets are each designed to accommodate 10,000 cars a day. 

People are saying there must be an ulterior motive behind the South Street closure. Is anyone benefiting from the switch?

No one is benefiting from the design except the audience, who will still have access to a fantastic annual concert lineup. We are not displacing any homes or businesses by closing this block, and no one is getting paid or benefiting from this closure. 

How does the closure of the block of South Street affect the Chavis-Dix Strollway? 

We have incorporated the Strollway concept into our design, making it a catalyst for the design and construction to begin. I see it as a huge win! We will be investing significant dollars to this effort and, coupled with the federal dollars already committed, this will almost double the Strollway budget and launch the concept into reality. This is an excellent opportunity to work with engaged strollway advocates on design and other features of the path. 

Many are concerned the proposed plans have no room for public opinion. Why did the convention center opt to not take public input? 

This is a purpose-built venue. It has many parameters that it must meet in order for it to successfully host concerts, satisfy artist needs and provide a safe experience for guests. The exercise to this point has been one of math—fitting the geometric shape necessary on the land we have. We’re making sure the direction of sound is appropriate for a quality experience, studying sightlines and viewing angles that’s necessary from each direction, and adding in the next layers such as restrooms, industry standard concessions, artist needs, etc. It is really a ‘fit the spaces into the site’ exercise which doesn’t provide an opportunity for creativity from the community. We do intend to seek out public engagement on elements where we have more flexibility, specifically the strollway design.

If the relocated amphitheater is built, will any seats be covered to provide shade and protect from inclement weather? 

Yes, some seats will be covered and a greater number than now. The final number is still to be determined. As an additional plus, the new Capital Square condo directly behind us shades the new location much earlier in the day than the old location.  

How many employees does it take to run a show at the amphitheater? What happens to those employees should the amphitheater get demolished? 

Live Nation uses approximately 130 people per evening, Sodexo uses approximately 70–80 per evening for food and beverage, and the City also has approximately six. Several staff [have] professions like schoolteachers, police wives and others who need a supplemental second income. Sadly, those positions would be gone with the cancellations of a show season. When we build the ice rink, we use people daily for a solid eight weeks, and those jobs would also be gone at a seasonal time when people are looking for extra spending money.

How is this another “DPAC moment,” and what potential impact will another loss like that have on the city? 

DPAC was born out of a failure to make a deal at our performing arts center years ago. The promoter built their own theater and booked the shows they owned there. We have never seen a Nederlander show at our venue since. It was a true pivot point where Raleigh lost a touring theater.

Now, we have an amphitheater that draws people Downtown to see top artists. Without a venue this size, concerts will skip Raleigh and perform in other cities like Wilmington and Charlotte only. Again, Durham is paying attention and has proposed an amphitheater in its tourism plan. If we lose an entertainment draw this time, we know the economic impact is likely catastrophic to our Downtown, where businesses see a 20 to 50% uptick on show days—therefore, it’s a risk for the whole city.   

*Answers have been lightly edited for length and clarity.

Setting the Record Straight on Red Hat Amp

Setting the Record Straight on Red Hat Amp

The Raleigh rumor mill has been churning around the fate of Red Hat Amphitheater—and a key figure sits at its core whose unique position carries massive gravitas—the trifecta if you will. Now, in a sit-down interview with Raleigh Magazine, mayoral candidate, South Street resident and current Dix Park Conservancy CEO Janet Cowell sets the record straight.

Despite public speculation regarding her alleged opposition, “I am in support of keeping Red Hat Downtown,” says Cowell, whose last day as Dix Park Conservancy CEO is Oct. 4. When asked, to be clear, how she would vote today if it meant closing South Street, she replied: “I think you’re going to see this council vote yes; I would vote yes—if this was the absolute best we could do.”

That said, the current plan that includes the South Street closure is by no means ideal to Cowell. “There’s a lot of water under the bridge. But this is where we are: We know we want it Downtown. This is the location. So I think it’s these final questions of: Are you telling me there can’t be two-way traffic? Is this the best we can do?”

She notes closing a street is a really serious decision, and with that allowing for as much vehicular throughput, pedestrians and bicycles is a “win-win for everybody in Southern Downtown,” she says. 

That dream of a win-win largely hinges on the “everybody”—specifically massive affordable housing project Heritage Park (one of Raleigh’s biggest), where residents could be detached from Downtown by South Street’s closure. That said, the street sees relatively little traffic, just 3,300 cars daily (one-third the 10K it was built for). 

“All of these questions with Red Hat are relevant to Heritage Park—not only are you trying to create more units, but you have existing residents who have been through a lot and displaced,” maintains Cowell. Heritage Park has long been under redevelopment plans to multiply the number of affordable and mixed-income units on that site, “and the redevelopment of that site does depend on some of these roads and networks and access,” she adds.

“I think that’s what we’re pushing for—have you absolutely gone to the mat on the negotiations on the design with NCDOT,” she continues, “and have you pushed for the absolute best long-term solution for Southern Downtown—because I live there; I’ve invested in it; I’m writing grants; I want this to be a very successful area for everybody.”

As far as other rumors regarding her potential conflict of interest in discreetly angling to have DTR Red Hat Amp fail in lieu of a Dix Park relocation, Cowell sets the record straight on that as well. To be clear, Dix Park Conservancy has absolutely no formal position on the matter, but Cowell confirms that while there is an amphitheater in the Dix master plan, it’s not this kind of amphitheater. Think less 7K screaming fans at Lizzo and more picnic baskets, Theatre in the Park vibes. It’s really just “an unfortunate diversion of attention,” she says. 

Ultimately, she says, “[Red Hat’s] good energy for Downtown; it keeps Downtown as a regional arts and tourist destination, so I think there are a lot of positives. … Everybody wants Downtown to do well. I think this is all going to go through.”

Coming Soon: 10 most-asked questions about Red Hat Amp relocation answered. Subscribe to Raleigh Insider.

red hat south street rendering

Raleigh Mayoral Candidates Weigh in on Red Hat’s Future

Are you in favor of Red Hat Amphitheater staying Downtown or moving to Dix Park? 

Terrence Ruth
“The location of the Red Hat Amphitheater should be determined by what best serves the community’s needs and enhances the cultural vibrancy of Raleigh. Keeping it Downtown supports local businesses and maintains the city’s cultural hub. However, moving it to Dix Park could offer unique opportunities, but the fragile nature of our Downtown requires the city’s full attention. I would advocate for extensive community input before making a decision.”

Paul Fitts
“Leave it where it is.”

Eugene Myrick
“I am not in favor of moving the Red Hat Amphitheater to Dix Park. While the amphitheater is a beloved venue, relocating it would have significant and far-reaching consequences that outweigh the potential benefits. Moving the amphitheater would negatively impact local businesses that have long benefited from its downtown location. The foot traffic and economic activity generated by events at Red Hat Amphitheater support our small businesses, which are the backbone of our local economy. Disrupting this ecosystem could lead to closures and lost livelihoods for many who rely on this steady stream of patrons.”

James Shaughnessy IV
“I am in favor of keeping Red Hat Amphitheater Downtown. It’s become a cultural staple in the area and plays a vital role in supporting local businesses by driving foot traffic and generating economic activity. Its presence Downtown is beneficial both for the economy and the cultural vibrancy of the city.”

Red Hat Amp’s fate will be decided on Sep. 17. If Raleigh City Council doesn’t pass the proposed plans to expand and relocation it, Red Hat Amphitheater will be demolished for good—there is no alternative plan.