How Five Points residents, an architect and Hayes Barton Baptist Church came together in compromise.
The house at 1814 White Oak Road, a classic-frame craftsman bungalow, is painted white, with hardwood floors, a covered porch and an original decorative fireplace.
Though charming, there’s not much to distinguish it from other historic homes in Raleigh’s old Five Points neighborhood. But for William Dodge, who lived in the home in the ’90s as a teenager with his educator parents—roaming the streets with neighborhood kids, playing basketball on the church’s parking lot courts—it was the house that made him want to study to become an architect.
William Dodge
Hayes Barton Baptist Church, located at the pinnacle of the Five Points intersection if you’re traveling north on Glenwood from downtown, is one of the best-known buildings in Raleigh. Built in 1926, the sprawling building’s towering spire, its classical columns and beige-toned brick and trim work make it iconic in most residents’ minds.
A little over a year ago, the church’s pastor, Dr. David Hailey, announced plans to tear down six homes, all constructed between 1921 and 1930, that the church owned on adjacent White Oak Road—including 1814—to accommodate its growing membership. The church, which had been renting the homes at affordable prices for decades to students and working class families such as Dodge’s, needed space to build a parking lot in order to better serve senior and disabled congregants and parents dropping off and picking up their young children.
Dr. David Hailey
As often happens in Raleigh when the old and less monied are perceived as being forced out to accommodate the new and wealthy—whether it’s property, or people, or both—residents living nearby were indignant. As well as upset over the prospect of losing the historic houses—all are included in the Bloomsbury Historic District on the National Register of Historic Places, part of the fabric of a neighborhood that, uniquely for Raleigh’s older districts, has remained intact for over a century—neighbors feared for their children’s safety due to increased traffic that the parking lot could generate on one-way White Oak Road and exacerbated issues with stormwater runoff, an already existing problem.
Tempers flared. Picket signs imploring the church to “Save Six” went up in front yards all over Five Points and beyond.
But what followed wasn’t an acrimonious, drawn-out battle between a powerful parish and a group of principled preservationists, or a rightful property owner and a bunch of NIMBYs, depending on the perspective.
Instead, last month, the neighbors and church leadership reached a compromise, encoded in a memorandum of understanding, that presents a solution to the church’s needs while still seeking to preserve at least three of the houses on White Oak Road. All parties agree that the final master plan is a better one than existed before, both for the church and for the neighborhood.
And there’s a real possibility that all six of the homes could eventually be saved.
Yard signs urging the church to preserve the six homes
A Contentious Beginning
The Five Points CAC meeting was packed on March 21 of last year.
Hailey, who had presented a conceptual framework of the church’s expansion plans to his congregation earlier that month had sent volunteers to knock on neighbors’ doors and pass along the information. This is where the trouble started.
“[The plan] was not presented to us that this was a proposal,” said Jennifer Williams, a White Oak resident and Save Six organizer, at the CAC meeting that night. “It was presented that this was a done deal and that this would be good for us. We could barely react. We were handed a pamphlet that seemed very official and it was like, ‘This is what we’re doing, it’s going to be good for you and will be good for the neighborhood.’”
“The neighbors felt we locked them out,” Hailey says. “And I guess we did lock them out. But it wasn’t malicious. So at the meeting, there was a high level of contention.”
“Serious anxiety and contention,” Dodge adds. “People were yelling at people.”
“The uproar had already begun in the press,” Hailey says, “and we determined when we went to the meeting, we’d tell a little bit of the story. And then, we were just going to listen.”
Though emotions were running high, both church leaders and neighbors insisted they didn’t want an adversarial relationship with one another. And, during the meeting, it became clear that the church was open to taking suggestions. Dodge—who by then hadn’t had anything to do with the church for two decades, though he still had friends in the area and frequented Hayes Barton Café and the Five Points post office—approached Hailey and offered to lend his expertise.
The two sat down together a few weeks later.
“I had just started as one of the partners at a new architecture firm,” Dodge recalls. “My friend is the CEO and I told him, ‘I think I just found the most high-profile, contentious, non-paying project ever. Aren’t you super excited about that?’”
Turns out, he was.
Dodge and his design partner, Jesse Green, at Hanbury—an architecture and planning firm—acted as pro bono outside design advisers in order to help both the neighborhood and the church resolve many of the issues raised in the church’s initial plan. Over several months, Dodge and Green were able to draw up a master plan that gives the church its expanded parking, as well as the accessibility and flexibility it needs, while still preserving three of the homes—1814, 1816 and 1818—onsite.
“We kept going back and forth, like can we try to get by with just two houses being removed,” Dodge says. “But it really needed handicap accessibility parking and that just wouldn’t have given them enough. That was not an easy thing for me to say. I love these houses and am very familiar with them. But we were trying to create a community dynamic between the overall neighborhood and the church and ultimately, this is the best possible solution that could have happened.”
Durham-based landscape architecture firm Surface 678 will install landscaping between White Oak Road and the parking lot and the civil engineering firm WithersRavenel will work with the church in order to realize the master plan while also providing an enhanced but inviting landscape buffer as well as mitigating stormwater issues.
Furthermore, Hayes Barton Baptist Church is exploring ways to create a joint partnership with its neighbors to develop the three homes for affordable housing.
“We want to be a little more intentional,” Hailey says. “We understand that to create a community and a home, you need not only a safe shelter but a welcoming community. We want to partner with the neighborhood in providing that welcoming community. We look at the homes as part of our mission, as part of a ministry strategy.”
But there won’t be any proselytizing, Hailey clarifies. Instead, the church wants and welcomes diversity. He’s looking at the Catholic Church’s “Support Circle” model, where communities support families in acclimating to their new neighborhoods.
1810 and 1806 White Oak Road
Loving Your Neighbor
By most accounts, the Save Six saga is a Raleigh success story. When church and community leaders signed the MOU last month, dozens of neighbors turned out to witness it, bringing their kids, exchanging hugs and posing for group pictures.
“We can’t help but see this as a symbol of community,” said Vernon Hunter, a Five Points resident involved in the negotiations. “Despite our different needs, we were able to come together as neighbors and reach an agreement that works for everyone involved.”
“I applaud the neighbors for coming to the table,” Hailey says. “It was hard for them to think about removing three houses.”
Hailey also applauds Dodge: “He was a bridge to the past and a bridge to the future.”
And Dodge applauds Hailey: “99 percent of people in [his] situation would not care what the neighbors have to say.”
So, the biblical parable is clear: It’s about loving your neighbor.
“It saved three houses but built multiple relationships,” Hailey says. “[Dodge] and I met through this and I promise there will be times in the future when I pick up the phone and call him because we built this friendship. Sometimes, what appears to be your worst experience ends up being your best, because it becomes a pathway. You can’t get to the promised land except through the wilderness.”
“It’s almost been, in a cheesy way, a love story,” Dodge says. “It could not have come together better. It’s funny, this is by far the most time I’ve spent in a church in 30 years. But I grew up in this house, trained as an architect, know nothing about the Baptist church but I go to a meeting, have a conversation and it turns out to be this really cool project that at least saved three houses. Maybe all.”
Maybe all?
Indeed, what will become of the other three houses—1806 White Oak Road, another craftsman bungalow, 1810, a Dutch Colonial Revival, and 1812, an American Foursquare?
In the best-case scenario, the church, already raising money to get the plan underway, can partner with someone in real estate with the means to physically move the homes onto vacant lots elsewhere in Five Points, or in Raleigh. It’s been done here before.
“That would be a great outcome,” Hailey says. “We would be delighted to try and make that happen.”
In any event, the Five Points bungalow that inspired an architect—and brought together a community—is here to stay.
It may be only one word but “faith” embodies a varied and personal set of beliefs.
We explore the wealth of religious diversity that exists in our city.
Raleigh Magazine wanted to write a story about the diversity of religion in the Triangle. It was an ambitious idea, and I jumped at the opportunity. I knew the story would be challenging, but I didn’t realize how deeply it would affect me.
Over the course of researching this article, I grieved with my own congregation at a Catholic funeral, saw the joy of a soccer mom introducing a widely misunderstood faith to her friend, had coffee with a leader of a church whose journey with his transgender daughter informed his ministry, and spoke with a former Sunday School teacher who, after missing the ritual of a religion she no longer believed in, found a different community with whom she could celebrate life.
I began to see that what I thought was an article on religion, was really a piece on relationships: our relationships with one another and with a Creator.
It was while I was in a mosque, where women surrounded me with love and welcome and were so excited about introducing their faith to Raleigh, that I was smacked with the arrogance of my original intent.
There is no way, within the pages of this magazine, within the limitations of words to express the love, beauty and solemnity of the many belief systems within our great city. There is not enough space to explain the complexity and nuances of each, and I don’t claim to possess the grace to convey the idea of faith itself.
So with deep humility, Raleigh Magazine presents these brief vignettes, snapshots of faith (and non-faith) communities in our area.
Finding Common Ground
Good Friday, 2016: the sanctuary was draped in black to commemorate the solemn day in Christianity when Jesus died on the cross. Pastor Mac Schafer knelt amid the blackness and asked for God’s help. His mind and spirit were low after a week of news about a House Bill that targeted his transgender daughter, and he wasn’t sure he had the strength to lead: “God, give me the energy to lead this service because I’m down. I’m so upset about HB2.”
“Pastor Mac?” A deacon quietly interrupted his prayers. “The Easter lilies are here.”
The symbol was all he needed. Throughout his journey with his transgender daughter, Hunter, Pastor Mac knew that God was with him, and it was all going to be OK.
Hunter was only in 4th grade when Schafer moved to Raleigh and joined Hudson Memorial Presbyterian Church. Though Schafer suspects Hunter already knew something was different, she didn’t come out to them until much later.
“When Hunter came out to us initially, she was in middle school, being raised as our son, and she told us she was gay,” says Schafer. Already open to that possibility, Schafer and his wife, Katy, reaffirmed their love and acceptance. It was a couple years later that Hunter told them she was transgender.
“There was more adjustment for us at that point,” Schafer admits. “Part of that was our own ignorance in not understanding what somebody being transgender meant, but there is also the inner grief you feel as a parent saying goodbye to what you thought life was going to be like for your child.”
Schafer says there were moments along the way that helped him let go of control and fear for his daughter. One such moment was when she addressed concerns over changing for health class. She scheduled a meeting with the guidance counselor and, though her parents were there, she took charge.
“Hunter sat down and said, ‘I wanted to talk to you about health class. I’m transgender, do you know what that means?’” Schafer laughs recalling the initial look on the counselor’s face, whom he says, composed herself quickly and handled it very well.
It didn’t matter if Hunter was Schafer’s son or daughter; his child was a strong person, and Schafer was a proud dad. “She has the characteristic of knowing who she is and asserting what her needs are,” he says.
Professionally, Pastor Mac didn’t hide his daughter’s journey, but it also wasn’t necessarily public knowledge. One family trip and a social media post changed that.
Schafer was graduating from a doctoral program in Pittsburgh and Hunter asked if she could wear a dress publicly for the first time. Knowing there was family present who didn’t know the full story, Schafer asked her to wait and wear the dress at the National Cathedral in Washington, D.C., where they were going to stop for mass on the way home.
Unbeknownst to the Schafer family, that National Cathedral mass celebrated a group baptism. The priest walked through the congregation with sprigs of holy water, blessing everyone: “For Hunter, I think she was just glad to be wearing her dress, but for my wife and me, it was a very powerful moment of Hunter standing, as a transgender girl, being blessed as a child of God.”
To commemorate the day, the family took a picture in front of the Cathedral. Mac and Katy thought it would be a nice photo for the family; their daughters thought a little bigger.
“We are driving down 95 and I hear Hannah say, ‘I can’t believe you posted it!’ and Hunter says, ‘Isn’t it great? We got 200 likes already!” In very short order, Schafer got a text from an elder at his church that said, “Is everything OK?”
Upon coming home to news and questions, the youth director advised Schafer to tell his story before others told it for him. The Schafer family held two town hall style meetings, first with the youth group and then with the congregation.
“Hunter told her story as a transgender teenager, Hannah told her story as a sibling, and Katy and I told our stories as parents,” says Schafer. “The whole experience was uplifting and powerful for our family and, I think, for the congregation.”
“I had folks in the church who I know struggle with the idea of gay marriage or other LGBT issues, but a lot of them came up to me and said, ‘Look, regardless of my struggles with what I believe, we love you,’ and I think that’s the balance that we’ve been able to strike,” Schafer says.
In each of these conversations, whether supportive or questioning, Schafer puts the relationship first, always looking to find common ground. The bottom line, he says, is “It’s not the end of the discussion, but it’s a great marker to be able to have that discussion, tell that story and everyone respects each other; maybe even loves each other in a new and different way.”
It has transformed the way Schafer approaches both ministry and conversation in a cultural sense. “I don’t think people change by my arguing my views on Scripture or by amping up confrontation,” he says. “I think people are changed when they know people and their stories; it humanizes us.”
Schafer says though he doesn’t use his pulpit to advocate for specific social issues, the journey has also informed his faith. “In the Gospels, whenever religious leaders had a rule they were trying to enforce that inhibited people from experiencing the Kingdom of God, Jesus would bat up against it in the spirit of liberating the oppressed,” Schafer says.
At the core of Schafer’s belief about God is love. He ends almost every service with the following benediction: “Be strong and courageous, stand firm in your faith, let all you do be done in love, may you know God’s smile and that you are loved beyond your wildest imagination.”
And though his family’s fight with HB2 is ongoing, the support of his church community and signs of God’s grace like lilies through darkness, keep Pastor Mac optimistic that love and compassion will win in the end.
Beneath the Dome
A new Catholic cathedral gives a local, growing population a Mother Church
The construction of a new Cathedral is incredibly rare. While many dioceses around the country are consolidating schools and parishes, the Diocese of Raleigh is in the very unique position of having a booming Catholic population where the former Cathedral is not feasible for renovation.
The current Cathedral, Sacred Heart in downtown Raleigh began serving as the Diocese’s central church in 1924 when the Catholic population for all of North Carolina was only 6,000. With limited parking and a seating capacity of 320, the Cathedral held several services on Sundays and even had to rent hotel space nearby to handle overflow masses on holy days.
Currently the Raleigh diocese is home to 500,000 Catholics with projections of reaching 1 million in less than 20 years. The growing population of transplants, along with the Hispanic migrant population, which is primarily Catholic, has made our area one of the top four fastest growing Catholic populations in the country.
It was clear, a new Mother Church was needed. The Cathedral Campaign was announced with a commitment by Bishop Burbidge (the former Bishop of Raleigh, now Bishop of Arlington, VA) to only spend what the people of God would provide. And the great majority of the budget came during the initial campaign from faithful Catholics excited to fulfill the dream of a Cathedral with the ability to host diocesan liturgical events.
On January 3, 2015, the dream became reality as the Diocese of Raleigh celebrated the Rite of Blessing and Groundbreaking for the Holy Name of Jesus Cathedral. The Cathedral will sit on the Nazareth property off Western Boulevard which used to be home to a Catholic Orphanage (which housed the Holy Name of Jesus chapel) and the old Cardinal Gibbons High School.
Over the last two years, Raleighites have watched the campus transform, most notably when the 162-ton copper-topped dome was lifted atop the structure, an incredible architectural feat that took 31 minutes of active crane movement to lift into place. The dome took 16,000 hours of man hours to build, and 25 tractor-trailers were needed to transport the crane that was required to lift it.
Billy Atwell, Director of Communications for the Diocese of Raleigh, says: “We have received feedback from people all around Raleigh saying that they have seen the dome from the most unlikely of places. It’s becoming a reference point for the downtown area.”
Stained-glass windows that measure up to 17 feet high and Stations of the Cross were rescued from the Ascension Parish in Philadelphia, which closed down. The windows are being restored by Beyer Studio in Philadelphia before being installed. A 50-bell carillon commissioned for the Cathedral will mark hours of worship as well as play songs for special events.
The building is in the shape of a cruciform that “connects our diocesan Cathedral with the many Cathedrals found in Rome and throughout the world that express a similar shape. The cruciform gives our beautiful new Cathedral a timeless appearance that will hold up throughout the ages,” says Atwell.
The Cathedral will open and be dedicated on July 26. Though the Cathedral will, of course, hold special significance for the Catholic population, Atwell invites everyone to come and see this architectural wonder. “We want the community to feel welcome to join us and celebrate this wonderful, sacred site in Raleigh,” he says.
Answering the Call
A visit to the Islamic Center of Raleigh during Friday Prayers
I’m not someone who normally picks out outfits ahead of time; but there I was, in my closet, ensuring I had an appropriate outfit for my assignment the next day when my phone chirped: “I just found out a friend of mine goes to the Islamic Center of Raleigh. She said she’d love to come with us.”
The text was from my friend Jeana who, when she heard that I was going to be visiting different places of worship, volunteered to join me.
We were both excited to go to the Islamic Center of Raleigh that Friday, but admittedly, I was a little nervous. I wanted to make sure I was respectful of the dress, the customs and the service. I didn’t want to do or say something to make anyone feel uncomfortable in their place of worship, especially with the amount of negativity and uncertainty in the current political and media climate. When I learned Jeana’s friend Tahani would join us, it was a welcome addition.
Jeana and I picked Tahani up, and immediately I knew this would be an unforgettable afternoon. Dressed traditionally, Tahani greeted us in her driveway with a smile that stretched from hem to hem of her hijab. She was excited to share her faith with us and thanked us for taking the time to learn.
Hugging Jeana and hopping in the car, the two caught up on kids and families. They were friends from CASL soccer and joked that it was an educational team; the parents taught each other how to shout from the sidelines in Arabic, English and Spanish.
For the rest of the ride I peppered Tahani with questions about common phrases like, “Inshallah,” (If Allah wills it, or God willing) and “As-Salaam-Alaikum” (Peace be unto you). I had read that it was polite to greet others at the mosque with the latter phrase, and we spent time attempting to perfect our pronunciation.
After a while, Tahani politely and in good humor insisted it’s ‘totally fine’ to also just say, ‘salaam,’ or even, ‘hi.’
Upon walking in the building, two gentlemen greeted us. “Salaam Sister,” to Tahani and, “Welcome, are you visiting to learn about Islam?” to us. We veered to the right to take the elevator to the 2nd floor where the women’s masjid (mosque) is located. We removed our shoes in the hallway and stepped through the doors. Most women sat on the floor, but there were also folding chairs along the back of the room.
A closed-circuit television hung in the front where women watched the Imam give a lesson from the men’s masjid downstairs. After the lesson (khutba), which usually lasts 20 to 30 minutes, the Imam leads the Salah, the mid-day prayer. Within the Salah, there are usually two to four rakats, or repetitions of prayer. Each rakat incorporates words, sung in Arabic, giving praise to God, and movement, which includes standing and bowing prostrate to God, touching forehead to ground. The prayers lasted five to 10 minutes, after which the women either returned to sitting in thoughtful prayer, or stood to visit with friends.
It was at this time when Jeana and I were welcomed warmly by many women. One approached us and invited us to tea on Sunday, a weekly opportunity to meet Muslim women and learn more about Islam. I thanked her for her invitation, but knowing I was unable to make it, asked her what was one thing she wished people knew about her faith.
“That we are not terrorists,” she said.
The answer came without hesitation and it stunned me, just how openly, how beseechingly she said it. She explained that when she walks through the city with her head covered, people ask her why she is so extreme. She sees their looks of fear.
My heart broke for her. My mind went instantly to the cruciform necklace that was underneath my layers of clothing. I don’t think twice about wearing a symbol of my faith. I tried to imagine what it would feel like to get looks of fear or anger anytime I wore my cross. Would I still have the courage to wear it?
“We cover ourselves so that we are not concerned with our outside. Our concern is with our inside. We want to direct all our thoughts and energy to becoming good on the inside, not only for God but for others,” she explained.
I nodded at a notion I can surely appreciate, especially as my daughter nears the teenage years which can be hard on a girl’s self esteem: equating hair, clothes, complexion and popularity with boys with self-worth. The hijab may seem foreign to me, but her explanation behind it resonated.
Before we walked away from the woman that greeted us, I realized how we might be seen as intruders in this place, the one place they may feel truly at ease dressing in accordance with their faith. So I asked, “Knowing that there is so much misunderstanding, does it make it uncomfortable for outsiders, like me, to be in your place of worship?”
She shook her head: “We like it very much. We want people to know who we really are.”
Unbound Abundance
Sunday Assembly celebrates community without religion
Mandi Kaye Ottaway spent the first 25 years of her life going to church every Sunday. A member of an independent Baptist church, Mandi taught Sunday School, Vacation Bible School and sang in the choir. Over time, however, she felt a shift in how she viewed her faith community.
“I began to feel as if people were less important than doctrine, which I felt went against the teachings of the Bible,” Ottaway says.
She explored other Christian denominations and asked deeper questions, challenging the faith that she had held for most her life: “I realized that I’d spent my life parroting what I’d been told without ever questioning it, and when I started picking at it, everything just fell away.”
When Ottaway decided that religion was no longer part of who she was, she missed the community of a multi-generational weekly gathering. It was a hole in her life that she wasn’t sure how to fill until she discovered Sunday Assembly.
Sunday Assembly is a global movement started in 2013 by Sanderson Jones and Pippa Evans, two comedians from London. They were en route to a job when they discovered they both had the desire to do, ‘something that felt like church but totally secular and inclusive of all—no matter what they believed.’
By their second Assembly, 300 people had joined, and requests poured in from all over the world for permission and guidance to start additional chapters. Today there are over 70 Sunday Assembly chapters in eight different countries. The motto, ‘Live Better, Help Often, Wonder More,’ underscores the mission to be a supportive and accepting community.
It has been called, ‘The Atheist Church,’ but Heather Greer Klein, board vice chair of the Chapel Hill Sunday Assembly, says that moniker is not entirely accurate. “Sunday Assembly aims to create a space for community regardless of belief,” says Greer Klein.
“When Sunday Assembly started, we actually got a lot of pushback from hardcore atheists who thought even our ‘non-religious’ message was too close to church, and they had just been so burned that they didn’t want any part of it,” says Kevin Klein, Heather’s husband and board chair.
Held on the second Sunday of every month at the ArtsCenter in Carrboro, the Assembly structures the hour-long event around a theme with music, speakers and an opportunity for members to share life events.
The Sunday Assembly band is a rotating cast of attendees who range in age from seven to 70 and who lead attendees in uplifting pop songs such as, “Here Comes the Sun,” by the Beatles or “Roar,” by Katy Perry. The speakers are carefully chosen to present 20-minute talks about a wide swath of themes, including goal setting, supporting others through grief and space exploration. Speakers must follow guidelines and policies that highlight the idea that Sunday Assembly is a place of acceptance.
To underscore the importance of this idea, Greer Klein refers to the words of founder Sanderson Jones: “Your religious grandma should be able to come to Sunday Assembly and see nothing that happens that is offensive to her.”
And for Ottaway, she has found a way to celebrate “the one life she knows she has.
Everything I Needed to Know about Visiting a New Place of Faith, I learned from the Kadampa Center
Visiting places of worship outside your tradition can be an incredibly enriching experience. Yet many of us are nervous to ‘do the wrong thing.’ To help, here are some tips, and I learned them all while visiting the Kadampa Center for the Practice of Tibetan Buddhism in Raleigh.
Be honest. Let people know it’s your first time and you are visiting and curious. Greeters at the Kadampa Center gave me a brief tour and incredible welcome.
Follow the Leader. Upon entering the Kadampa Center, I followed a gentleman who seemed to know his way around. He walked past the entrance to a line of turning wheels. “Turn for world peace,” they instructed. I followed his lead and spun the wheels. It is hard to describe, but that outward physical act, to express the intention for peace in my heart was powerful.
Respect your own comfort level. Upon sitting down in the gompa (teaching hall), the woman sitting beside me, Hettie, explained how some will prostrate, not as worship but to combat pride. I wasn’t sure I fully understood the concept, so I remained respectfully seated.
Smile! This I learned directly from the teacher, Gesha Galek during the teaching. When you smile at people, you bring more kindness into your life and you let people know that you are there with peace and love in your heart.
Just be. You are not going to become an expert in a day, so don’t try. Don’t worry if you don’t understand every ritual or if everyone laughs and you missed the joke. At the teaching I went to, Gesha Galek had just returned from India and was sharing stories from the monastery. Many people had also been to India, so there were many references I didn’t necessarily catch, but I was able to soak in the feeling of family this Center shared.
Websites are your friend. The Kadampa Center, like many places of worship, has a page on their website with frequently asked questions and tips on when to come and what to wear.
Say thank you. The community is sharing something that is sacred to them. Thank them for their welcome and kindness. At the end of the teaching, there is a generosity ritual. We lined up to present a token gift to the teacher. If you did not bring one, but wanted to participate, a basket of scarves to borrow is provided. I waited a long time and watched the others before I decided this was something I wanted to do. I pulled a scarf and waited in turn as each person approached Gesha Galek. At my turn, I offered him the scarf and said, “Thank you.” He presented it back to me, draped the scarf across my neck, looked me in the eyes and said, “Thank you.”