As Downtown Raleigh looks to squash crime and disarray, we press local leaders, business owners and stakeholders for their solutions.
No matter how you spin it, Downtown Raleigh has fallen on hard times. Reported crimes have increased by 60% in the last eight months, compared to the same timespan last year. That rapid rise is starting to deter both Raleighites and visitors from venturing to the area, thus affecting businesses and our economy—and it could affect our status as one of the top five places to live in the country.
Serious crimes—shootings, stabbings, robbings, assaults, harassment, vandalism, drug deals and the like, not to mention loitering and panhandling—combined with the city’s growing homelessness problem, substance abuse and fewer police on the streets, has created the perfect storm. In terms of the police presence, Raleigh Police Department is redistributing officers Downtown from all over the city, but it’s not sustainable—especially given there’s only 700 or so officers on the force right now (think ~80 vacancies). Though RPD Chief Estella Patterson acknowledges a city of this size should have closer to 1,100 officers, and hopes to ultimately get us there.
While Glenwood South has gotten much recent attention for disorder, crime has pervaded portions of Fayetteville and Davie streets and around the GoRaleigh bus station as well. “St. Roch is in a unique position, as we share an entrance with the transit center, so we are in the middle of the action and truly see it all,” says chef/owner Sunny Gerhart. “We have certainly felt the blowback of the unsavory activity Downtown for the last few months. Our business has seen a 17% reduction in sales over the last two months compared to the same time period last year.”
Nevertheless, Gerhart and fellow business owners, along with City Council members, Mayor Mary-Ann Baldwin, RPD and Downtown Raleigh Alliance, are committed to navigating and overcoming these challenges and working toward both short- and long-term solutions.
Already, RPD has increased its presence Downtown via bike and foot patrols, utility vehicles, and special motorbikes that can weave in and out of parking decks to look for drug deals and other crimes; while DRA has increased its ambassador and social worker presence for those who need further assistance.
“In the last four weeks we have had 500 enforcement actions [arrests and citations] Downtown,” said Captain Jon Wood, Downtown District Commander of the Field Operations Division, during the Downtown Rundown Oct. 17. DRA also hired a private security firm to patrol areas of DTR from 10am to 10pm seven days a week, starting Oct. 31 and continuing through June 30, 2024.
For its part, the City recently purchased a new security camera cloud network dubbed Fusus (also utilized in Atlanta) that knits together various public and private DTR cameras to help identify issues and collect evidence faster. It will also allow RPD to create a real-time crime center. The same camera system will be implemented in Glenwood South as well.
“I feel these efforts and our increased police presence are making a difference,” says Mayor Mary-Ann Baldwin. But, “we can’t arrest our way out of this problem,” maintains Patterson. And it’s going to take many proponents and tactics to overcome this situation. To dig into what that may look like, we tapped local leaders and stakeholders for their solutions.
Panhandling/Loitering Laws
Nowhere is Raleigh’s homelessness problem more apparent than Downtown. Aggressive loitering and panhandling have increased, especially near the GoRaleigh station. While panhandling is unlawful by the city municipal code without a permit (violation results in a misdemeanor), it’s rarely enforced.
Loitering is not currently against the law, with the exception of ordinances in specific locations, but many of the individuals we tapped believe that could help resolve DTR’s ongoing issues. However, “some of the challenges are between the city and state roads on how those laws are enforced,” says Council member Corey Branch, who represents District C, which includes parts of Downtown.
In the short-term, RPD is establishing measures to prevent loitering and trespassing after hours at the GoRaleigh bus station. “Our officers are strategically deployed during times when loitering is problematic,” maintains RPD Public Information Officer Lt. Jason Borneo. “This includes highly visible patrols throughout those areas after hours and enforcing city and state ordinances when applicable.”
Reduced Bus Fare
“While the bus station’s location has caused issues for nearby businesses lately, this wasn’t the case before the pandemic,” says The Davie owner Matt Coleman. GoRaleigh has been fare-free since March 2020, and in June, City Council voted to extend the policy through June 30, 2024. But some business owners and stakeholders believe the suspended fares have unintentionally resulted in the bus station becoming unsafe (case in point: RPD recently implemented a “zero tolerance approach” around the GoRaleigh bus station, which resulted in 274 charges in its first two weeks for crimes like trespassing, disorderly conduct, and illegal firearm and drug/drug paraphernalia possession)—and have proposed rolling back free fare.
“This is a really tough one because I was one of the champions of fare-free transit,” says stakeholder and DRA Economic Development Strategy committee member David Meeker, also the co-owner of Young Hearts Distilling on South Wilmington Street. “It’s painful because it feels like a couple hundred folks have ruined it for all the other riders who were really benefiting from free fare, but the system only works if it’s safe and it’s not always safe right now.”
Coleman agrees, but notes it’s important to recognize the transit system affects many parts of our city and nearby towns. “By offering a lower fare, we can discourage those who misuse the bus system and harm the community while still providing a useful service to those who are struggling financially,” he says. Patterson also recommends putting a system in place in which individuals would have to use an email address to access the Wi-Fi at the transit center, in hopes it would deter people from hanging around in the area.
City Council member Jane Harrison—who represents District D, which includes parts of Glenwood South—expects City Council to address the bus fare issue this month. But bringing back fares won’t solve everything. RPD is also working to expand the transit unit by assigning additional officers, as long as sufficient staffing in other areas of the city allows. In the meantime, increased private security around the transit center is a short-term fix.
Mental Health Services
In some cases, the root of these ongoing issues is poor mental health and a lack of immediate resources. According to Harrison, City Council has requested development of an independent crisis unit for nonviolent incidents, which will connect social workers with those in need. “I ask residents to stay tuned as this program will be discussed in a November Council meeting, and we will need significant community engagement to ensure its success,” she says.
Harrison also advocates for partnerships between Wake County and state government to strengthen social and public health services, including community violence intervention programs, substance use disorder support, increased shelter capacity and permanent housing for homeless individuals. “The first step is offering [programs] for those who truly need assistance,” echoes Branch.
City Council member-at-large Jonathan Melton has also asked the city manager about implementing a similar initiative to one in Wilmington in which signs are posted throughout Downtown encouraging folks to contribute money via QR codes to nonprofit providers who offer assistance to people experiencing homelessness, rather than giving money to panhandlers directly.
Moore Square Development
A longer-term solution to assist with the Downtown disarray includes the proposed development between the City of Raleigh and real estate developer Loden Properties on city-owned land to the south and east of Moore Square.
The project includes two new hotels, an apartment building with ~160 units designated for affordable housing, a grocery store, art studios, co-working space and more—as well as the rebuilding of homeless shelter Raleigh Rescue Mission near Moore Square on Hargett Street. Upon approval, Melton called it a “win-win-win for the city.”
In October, City Council voted to include three smaller parcels into the project, and in the next few months, Loden will begin negotiating with the city to buy the land before breaking ground.
Prepare for an e-bike boom this fall as the city sets an incentive program in motion.
Raleigh really wants you to give battery-powered biking a go. This fall, the city will roll out a pilot program dubbed Ral-E-Bike that incentivizes the purchase of electric bicycles (aka e-bikes). The goal? To encourage more residents to adopt this innovative form of transportation in their day-to-day lives.
“There are some other cities that have already done this; I think the most prominent example is Denver,” City Council member Jonathan Melton says of the program, which is funded through a federal grant. “It’s something I’ve been wanting to replicate in Raleigh for a long time.”
It’s no secret electric rides—including e-bikes—have exploded in popularity recently, a trend that’s proving to be a game-changer for urban transit. The Department of Energy estimates e-bikes can replace most car trips, given that 75% of U.S. car trips are less than 10 miles.
“We know e-bikes are better for the environment,” explains Melton. “We know if we can give folks options it’s going to reduce traffic so the people who want to drive cars or need to drive cars have a more enjoyable experience… and it also increases equity and mobility for people who can’t afford a car or don’t want to have a car.”
Through the program, Raleighites 18 and older can apply for $500 vouchers to use toward e-bike purchases from participating retailers; those with lower incomes can qualify for $1,500 vouchers. The initial pilot will allow for 75 income-qualified vouchers and 75 standard vouchers to be made available, and recipients will be asked to participate in regular surveys about their e-bike use.
“I’m hoping this pilot is a great success [and] we can use some of the information we gather to implement a long-term permanent program,” Melton shares. “Overall, I just want to see a mode shift in Raleigh. I think we’re very car-dependent right now, [but] we have a lot of exciting stuff on the horizon.” E-bike to the future? Count us in. raleighnc.gov
A new city council is being sworn in Dec. 5 at Union Station, including four new faces: Mary Black, Megan Patton, Jane Harrison and Christina Jones. Many have described this council as divided—and reelected Mayor Mary-Ann Baldwin as having to govern a council pitted against her. But, for her part, the mayor is optimistic. “People always want to paint negative pictures,” said Baldwin in a conversation with us one week post-election.
“This is the most diverse council in the history of Raleigh—and probably the youngest,” she said. “So I’m thinking, ‘I can’t wait to hear new ideas and these perspectives.’ And we have to respect that and all work together.” During and since the election, the council has been cast by nearly everyone as anti-growth vs. pro-growth. But the mayor doesn’t see it that way. “They actually are not anti-growth. They fall across lines of smart growth, and I think we share common values,” she said, including affordable housing, transit, small business and climate change, to name a few.
In talking to new council members, Baldwin says she thinks there could actually be a lot of unity and consensus within city council, which begins with building relationships and trust, listening to one another, and a willingness to compromise. Bottom line: “The campaign is over,” said Baldwin. “Now we govern. It’s not about activism. It’s about doing what’s best for our community.”
Are CACs the most divisive issue?
A hot-button issue leading up to the election and now anticipated to be one of the most divisive issues facing council are Citizen Advisory Councils (or CACs). If you aren’t familiar, you’re not alone. According to a city survey, more than 90% of residents had never heard of or been to a CAC—meaning this is a “hot-button issue” for a select few. That said, reinstating or revamping these advisory councils was also the central issue fueling some candidates to throw their hat in the ring for city council.
In short, CACs were intended to be nonpartisan advisory boards representing different geographical regions of the city, comprised of nonelected citizens. These councils routinely held meetings as a way of dispersing information and gathering public input. The CACs were disbanded without public input or notice in early 2020, a move for which Mayor Baldwin took much ire in the media. But, she says, her goal was to actually make community engagement more inclusive—not eliminate community engagement altogether. “My feeling is that CACs were exclusive, not inclusive, and we’re looking at ways to make community engagement inclusive.”
For their part, new District E Council Member Christina Jones served as former chairperson of the Raleigh Citizen Advisory Council. And new District D Council Member Jane Harrison reestablished the West Raleigh Community Advocacy Council and has vocally advocated for reestablishing robust community engagement. “Economic development should be community-centered, and city decisions must recognize the voices of the most affected groups, including historically marginalized communities and neighbors adjacent to a development,” Harrison told Raleigh Magazine. “We need forums like CACs and neighborhood associations to convene across the city, sharing information and developing leadership capacity to bring the best ideas forward.”
We asked Baldwin for her take on the return of CACs, and she nodded to the active community engagement board that council has asked to come up with ideas to move things forward. “I would like to see that community engagement board do its work and let us listen to them about what they think is needed,” she said. “And I hope we allow the community engagement board to do its work.”
ICYMI, Raleigh is getting its first social district (!). And Raleigh is super thrilled about it—a game-changer for the area and just the first step in making Fayetteville Street more attractive to bars, restaurants and consumers, and bringing more foot traffic to the area. The pilot program gives the city a chance to gather feedback and assess what is and isn’t working—and could lead to additional social districts throughout the city. But beyond all the brouhaha are a slew of lingering questions about the rules, what areas are included in the district, etc., so we talked to Raleigh City Council Member Jonathan Melton to get to the bottom of it all. Read on for what you need to know. Then, we’ll see you on the streets—designated to-go cup in hand, natch—starting Aug. 15!
What is a social district?
Specified areas where “people just walk around with a glass of wine or a beer, going into a store, sitting on a bench, etc.,” says Melton.
Where will Raleigh’s first social district be?
Fayetteville Street District—specifically Fayetteville Street from Capitol Building to Duke Energy Center, including Red Hat Amphitheater and City Market (borders = South, Blount, Morgan, Dawson), plus Warehouse District from Dawson to Union Station.
What are the rules?
The social district is effective seven days a week, from the hours of 11am–10pm.
You will only be able to carry a max 16 oz. designated cup (you cannot carry around a cup from home).
No glass is allowed.
You cannot bring a cup from one business to another.
Cups must be recycled upon exiting the district.
What’s included?
Several bars and restaurants are included in the designated social district, as well as Red Hat Amphitheater and Duke Energy Center. “An idea for the social district is that folks could go to dinner before a show, get a drink to go, and then walk down to the venue and finish the beverage before entering inside,” says Melton.
Why aren’t parks included?
Moore Square and Nash Square are NOT included in the social district at this time, based on city staff’s recommendation, says Melton. “I think they preferred we take an incremental approach to the social district and avoid areas that might be conducive to folks trying to bring their own alcohol into the social district, which isn’t allowed under the state law,” he expands. “Moore Square also already has its own ABC permit associated with the Square Burger on site. It’s a pilot program though, so we will continue to gather feedback and examine the boundaries over the next few months.” According to Melton, the city would have to construct a barrier to separate Square Burger from the rest of the park due to social district rules and the permit.
WEB EXCLUSIVEThe District D seat on Raleigh’s City Council has been open since June 26, when first-term Councilor Saige Martin resigned following a report detailing several alleged incidents of sexual misconduct against him.
Now, the council is tasked with selecting someone to replace Martin who will represent the district, which encompasses southwest Raleigh, including NC State University, and parts of downtown, for the next year and a half.
Starting July 1, District D residents interested in filling the vacancy, who are at least 21 years old and registered to vote in Wake County, have been submitting applications outlining their qualifications and interest in serving on the council. The city is collecting their resumes and publishing them on its website and applicants have until this Friday (July 9) at 4 p.m. to submit an application for consideration.
On Sunday (July 12) at 3 p.m., the council will select five applicants to participate in a virtual candidates forum. Members of the public may submit questions for the candidates to answer during the forum before 4 p.m. Friday.
A petition is circulating for Kay Crowder, who represented District D since 2014 before losing reelection to Martin last year, to fill the vacant seat. Crowder said she is interested in serving out the remainder of Martin’s term and her supporters argue the council is in need of a member with past experience in governing the city.
But it is unlikely the council will appoint Crowder. Mayor Mary-Ann Baldwin and Councilors Jonathan Martin and Nicole Stewart said they would like to see more diversity on the council and that they want underrepresented voices to have a place at the table.
We have the legal duty to appoint the next District D council member. And I think we have a moral duty to identify voices that are lacking at the table and provide access. Please help us identify a diverse pool of qualified candidates. #ralpolhttps://t.co/y3eZ4G7G8G
I have always been focused on bringing under-represented and diverse voices to the decision-making table. I am committed to finding an individual to appoint who represents voices who have been missing. 2/3
Council will likely appoint a candidate to represent District D next week. To apply as a candidate for District D online, click here. To submit a question for the candidate forum this Sunday, click here. To learn about the candidates who have applied so far, click here.