A recent raise got everyone talking about how our local government works—and why they earn what they do.
Few things have caused a stir in Raleigh quite like the announcement of the city manager’s pay raise at a December City Council meeting. The second-consecutive 10% pay increase raising Marchell Adams-David’s annual salary to $356,375 effective Jan. 1 (up from $323,978) effectively makes her the highest paid city manager in the Triangle—and second only statewide to Charlotte City Manager Marcus Jones.
That substantial raise—and income—has been the talk of the town all winter. Whether in the boardroom or at the bar, the banter was ubiquitous… sparking the repeated question: Why?
Pictured left: City Council; Pictured right: Marchell Adams-David
Why such a high salary?
Essentially, the City of Raleigh is the organization, and the Office of the City Manager is the administrative center, with the city manager at the helm. Thus, Adams-David executes and oversees the day-to-day operations of city government—think hirings, budget and beyond. In addition to coordinating and overseeing all City Department undertakings, supervising ~4,000 full-time city employees across those 20 departments, and proposing the city’s annual $1.3 billion budget to City Council, she serves as direct staff support for the mayor, City Council and committees, and as director of Raleigh’s future plans.
What does City Manager Adams-David do?
In short, Marchell Adams-David, who was appointed after serving ~6 1/2 years as assistant city manager, oversees a city of 472,540. Beyond her responsibilities to Raleigh’s nearly half-million population, her direct reports include four deputy/assistant managers who assist in research, public policy proposals, public program evaluation and direction of City Council, as well as a chief of administrative services, a chief of council services and, if approved in the budget, a new community relations analyst.
Why do city managers earn more than mayor/city council?
In North Carolina, according to the NC League of Municipalities, as dictated by General Charter, most municipalities—including Raleigh—are run in the form of council-manager, meaning the city manager is the chief policymaker, with city councils acting as the legislative body.
The city manager is thus the chief executive—similar to mayors in other major metropolitan areas, with one major caveat. She isn’t elected. Instead, the city manager is appointed as an administrator to implement the policies of the mayor-council, and execute and oversee the day-to-day operations of city government—think hirings, budget and beyond.
What does the mayor make?
According to the City of Raleigh, Raleigh Mayor Mary-Ann Baldwin earns an annual base income of $37,606 per the current adopted budget (FY23), up from a former $24,550 base. Implemented in December 2002, the boost was in accordance with a pay plan recommended by a September 2021 community study group as part of a concerted effort to increase mayor and council pay to full-time-worthy living wages.
The mayor pro-tem earns $33,203 and councilmembers $30,743, the latter up from an $18,021 base. As a point of note, these base salaries exclude additional compensation for car, technology, educational courses and other expenses. Insurance is also paid on their behalf.
According to the budget highlights in the FY24 Proposed Budget, “the City Council’s adopted budget includes personnel increases ($88,825) based on the new pay plan that was adopted by Council during the FY23 budget process,” as well as “benefit adjustments ($9,533) that account for increases in health care.”
City Manager Salaries
City Manager: $356,375 Deputy City Manager: $243,248 Asst. City Manager: $208,684 Asst. City Manager: $206,679 Asst. City Manager: $188,100
“And the south wind blew hard on that ragged old flag.” Johnny Cash’s famed lyric well encapsulates a rising movement for a new Raleigh flag—because “a great city deserves a great flag,” naturally. The MO behind the grassroots movement to bring “an iconic flag to Raleigh,” the move is part of a larger wave across the nation for cities to make their flags relevant—and hangworthy.
Why? Flashback to a 2015 TedTalk on “why city flags may be the ugliest thing you’ve never noticed.” Side note: Raise your hand if you knew Raleigh had a flag. Many of the smart, seasoned natives I polled did not. And, aye, there’s the rub.
For reference, the two-sided original—est. in 1899 and sewed by Kate Denson (for the trivia buffs)—shows, on one side, an oak tree surrounded by oak leaves and acorns with the words “City of Raleigh North Carolina, Established 1792.” On the reverse, an antlered deer upon a red-and-silver twisted tress sits atop a section of Sir Walter Raleigh’s coat of arms, imagined as a red shield intersected by connecting silver “diamonds” above the words “Amore et Virtue” (or, in English, “By Love and Valor”). Sounds simple, right?
The details are too complex and difficult to produce, explains Brian Rineer, one of the Raleighites leading the charge, who emphasized the updated eye-catching emblem’s simplicity and relevance, while retaining the essence of the historic flag. A flag, at its core, is an emblem that provides a sense of identity—a unifying symbol, a visual expression of civic pride. The new flag, which sports those five diamonds in a simplified iconic Raleigh acorn design, “doesn’t completely turn its back on the past—but pays homage to the past, while also moving the city forward, just as the city has moved forward over the years,” says Raleighite Joanne Sullivan, who first saw the revamped flag flying in the wild at neighbor Roland Kays’ abode and thought, ‘This is really a cool flag.’ … There’s something about the red and the big acorn—it doesn’t take itself too seriously.”
Well connected—think campaign volunteering and serving on the Raleigh Arts Commission and Parks and Rec Bond initiative, etc.—Sullivan has since been instrumental in elevating the status of the flag and getting the word out in the community by providing connectivity (businesses, elected officials…).
“It represents Raleigh in a very joyful way,” she adds. “It’s not stodgy. It’s very catchy. … You have the acorn. You have the shoutout to Sir Walter Raleigh with the crest. I think it’s something every generation can identify with—and see something and feel connected to. It does a great job representing Raleigh.”
For the record, this isn’t the first attempt to reno the Raleigh flag. Arguably never widely adopted, the 120-plus-year-old flag’s potential new design was a hot topic some six-ish years ago when residents called for an upgraded emblem to better rep Raleigh, with ideas flying about Twitter and Reddit—and as a matter of City Council discussion—to no end. Fast-forward to idle time and brilliant minds a la pandemic, and a group of residents resolved to revive the initiative, hence the New Raleigh Flag campaign. And—so far—as the bottom-up convo continues, no snubs yet.
What happens next is anyone’s guess—but for now: “It’s a great symbol,” says Sullivan. “It’s very distinct. Whether official or unofficial, it does a great job representing and celebrating our city.” newraleighflag.com
A new city council is being sworn in Dec. 5 at Union Station, including four new faces: Mary Black, Megan Patton, Jane Harrison and Christina Jones. Many have described this council as divided—and reelected Mayor Mary-Ann Baldwin as having to govern a council pitted against her. But, for her part, the mayor is optimistic. “People always want to paint negative pictures,” said Baldwin in a conversation with us one week post-election.
“This is the most diverse council in the history of Raleigh—and probably the youngest,” she said. “So I’m thinking, ‘I can’t wait to hear new ideas and these perspectives.’ And we have to respect that and all work together.” During and since the election, the council has been cast by nearly everyone as anti-growth vs. pro-growth. But the mayor doesn’t see it that way. “They actually are not anti-growth. They fall across lines of smart growth, and I think we share common values,” she said, including affordable housing, transit, small business and climate change, to name a few.
In talking to new council members, Baldwin says she thinks there could actually be a lot of unity and consensus within city council, which begins with building relationships and trust, listening to one another, and a willingness to compromise. Bottom line: “The campaign is over,” said Baldwin. “Now we govern. It’s not about activism. It’s about doing what’s best for our community.”
Are CACs the most divisive issue?
A hot-button issue leading up to the election and now anticipated to be one of the most divisive issues facing council are Citizen Advisory Councils (or CACs). If you aren’t familiar, you’re not alone. According to a city survey, more than 90% of residents had never heard of or been to a CAC—meaning this is a “hot-button issue” for a select few. That said, reinstating or revamping these advisory councils was also the central issue fueling some candidates to throw their hat in the ring for city council.
In short, CACs were intended to be nonpartisan advisory boards representing different geographical regions of the city, comprised of nonelected citizens. These councils routinely held meetings as a way of dispersing information and gathering public input. The CACs were disbanded without public input or notice in early 2020, a move for which Mayor Baldwin took much ire in the media. But, she says, her goal was to actually make community engagement more inclusive—not eliminate community engagement altogether. “My feeling is that CACs were exclusive, not inclusive, and we’re looking at ways to make community engagement inclusive.”
For their part, new District E Council Member Christina Jones served as former chairperson of the Raleigh Citizen Advisory Council. And new District D Council Member Jane Harrison reestablished the West Raleigh Community Advocacy Council and has vocally advocated for reestablishing robust community engagement. “Economic development should be community-centered, and city decisions must recognize the voices of the most affected groups, including historically marginalized communities and neighbors adjacent to a development,” Harrison told Raleigh Magazine. “We need forums like CACs and neighborhood associations to convene across the city, sharing information and developing leadership capacity to bring the best ideas forward.”
We asked Baldwin for her take on the return of CACs, and she nodded to the active community engagement board that council has asked to come up with ideas to move things forward. “I would like to see that community engagement board do its work and let us listen to them about what they think is needed,” she said. “And I hope we allow the community engagement board to do its work.”
If you ask Mayor Mary-Ann Baldwin, she’ll tell you, “We have a lot left to do.” She adds: “This council was elected to make change. And it takes more than two years to make change.” At the spring 2021 City Council Retreat, Baldwin laid out the five things our rapidly growing Cap City really needs to focus on for the next 20 years. Here’s her hot list in her own words and the questions Council must answer.
1. Dix Park
“How do we take this land we bought and turn it into that destination park we envisioned and hoped it would be five, 10, 15, 20 years from now?
2. PNC Arena
“What is its future? Where will the Hurricanes play? But it’s not just for the Hurricanes—PNC is also a space for NC State and Raleigh’s live music scene.”
3. Soccer Stadium
“I really see soccer as something that is inspirational and aspirational. We have the best women’s soccer team in the world right here—that’s something to celebrate. We also have the largest youth soccer program in the country, so this makes a lot of sense.
“Soccer is an international sport. When I went to the 919 to MLS at City Market, there were people there, from 8 months to 80 years old—every color, shape and size, speaking many languages. Soccer can bring people together. It’s about community-building. We can do this.
“If you’re talking about putting it in Downtown South, the big question is: How do we pay for it? But it could be that amphitheater like Red Hat that’s surrounded by amenities where people can walk or get on a BRT Line and be in the middle of downtown in five minutes. It gives options.”
4. Expansion of the Convention Center
“Red Hat was built to be a temporary structure. We’ve seen how it works. But as they say, we need heads in beds. Conventions do that. Now will conventions come back like they once were? We don’t know, but we have to think—again, 20 years out—what does that Convention Center look like, and how do we get that done?”
5. Civic Campus
(The new building that will house our employees). “Right now, we have employees strewn all over the city and in different places Downtown. So we’re spending money on leases—and people are not working together; there’s not as much efficiency. And, quite frankly, the Municipal Building is old, tired and dumpy. This is our growing capital city—one of the fastest growing cities in the country—and that’s how we’re running our government? So getting that Civic Campus complete—but more than that. We’re going to take some of the property around the block and start putting other uses there, which will help also build our tax base and add more uses around Nash Square. So that’s a big thing to think about. The other thing is: OK, if we are going to do this, how are we going to pay for it? So we need to convene a group of smart people who can figure this out [via a viability study].”
“There are things we still have left to do that are important to the future of our city. Government is a process—there’s a public engagement process that needs to take time. I believe we’re on the right track. We are providing leadership in areas where others have failed. We wanted to get not only the [Affordable] Housing Bond done—which we accomplished (thank you to the voters—72%)—but we want to get this Parks Bond done.”
WEB EXCLUSIVEUpdated: Raleigh’s curfew has been extended until 10 p.m. for Thursday, June 4to allow flexibility for businesses. It ends at 5 a.m. Friday morning. Raleigh’s City Council will host a virtual listening session at 7 p.m. for residents to share thoughts and concerns about the demonstrations of the past few days. Register here to speak; watch live here.
Following peaceful demonstrations that culminated in vandalism and looting in downtown Raleigh over the weekend, Mayor Mary-Ann Baldwin issued a State of Emergency and citywide curfew beginning June 1 at 8 p.m. and lasting until 5 a.m. on Tuesday, June 2.
In a statement posted on the City of Raleigh government’s Instagram, Baldwin said by setting a curfew she “hopes that this will allow our community to pause, collect ourselves, begin to repair the damage and turn our focus to the important work of finding connection and commonality.”
Below, we break down the rules set in place by the curfew.
Individuals are required to remain at home, with the exception of medical emergencies.
Travel is restricted within the city limits of Raleigh.
The curfew does not apply to medical professionals, public safety workers, hospital workers, military personnel, public transportation personnel, public utilities personnel and journalists.
Violators of the curfew will be charged with a misdemeanor and heavy fine—up to 60 days in jail and $1,000.
The curfew will remain in effect each until the mayor declares it’s over.