To answer everyone’s burning questions surrounding Raleigh’s impending Michelin Star status—and how those Stars are determined—RM went undercover with a Michelin Guide North America Chief Inspector, who, in true secret agent fashion, spoke to us anonymously to keep their identity tightly under wraps.
Are all five criteria balanced, or do some tip the scales?The Michelin Guide is unique because it evaluates only the cuisine itself. But it can also mention service quality and decor, and describe the experience you can get at a certain restaurant. They are weighed equally—applied in an identical manner around the world when assessing a restaurant.
Are inspectors still ex-chefs and industry pros? Yes. These former hospitality professionals all have at least 10 years of experience, which ensures they have a precise and technical knowledge of the field. They also receive extensive training in The Michelin Guide’s methodology, which is based on objective and universally deployable criteria.
Talk to us about Michelin’s methodology: How many tastings before dishing out Stars? Starred restaurants are always visited several times by different inspectors to ensure consistent quality and the satisfaction of our five criteria. The Guide doesn’t reveal specifics about the number of visits to a specific restaurant, the number of restaurants inspected, the destination assessment process or the inspectors’ methods.
Who picks the restaurants—and how? To compile a list of restaurants that warrant a visit,, the inspection teams explore destinations in person, as being out in the field is key. They also use various sources including local and national media, social media, and word-of-mouth recommendations.
Any Raleigh spots gunning for Michelin glory? The process is entirely independent and only The Michelin Guide Inspectors decide where to dine based on their experience in the field and research.
Pro tips for scoring the coveted Star? Your primary objective should be to fill your restaurants with happy customers who like to return. Cook for your patrons, not for Michelin. Do this on a consistent basis, and Michelin’s inspectors will find you.
Raleigh’s Michelin moment is almost here. With its Guide American South en route, RM tapped local restaurateurs to dish stars—and a Chief Inspector for answers. They didn’t hold back.
“Drew Maykuth’s fearless, adventurous creativity, humble spirit and thoughtful approach shine through every menu he creates, leaving me consistently inspired and joyful.”
“[Owner] Anthony has meticulously developed a high-volume, high-performing pizza—including a shockingly good gluten-free crust—that has become a must-visit icon for Downtown Raleigh. That would be enough, but he also happens to have one of the best wine and Champagne collections on the East Coast. A true Raleigh gem.”
“These restaurants, and, more importantly, these chefs, are some of the standard bearers in our area: outstanding food and service, dedication to our region, and all of the restaurants are very much extensions of the chefs themselves and really show their unique perspectives and personalities—folks who’ve always been and continue to be North Stars for me.”
“The food is consistently incredibly delicious, seasonal, awesomely creative—and [chef] Drew has a distinct point of view people really connect with through the food. It’s a place that is incredibly important to the Raleigh community.”
“It’s a fantastic steak done simply and perfectly—and has a comfort and familiarity you only get with an old-school family-run steakhouse that’s stood the test of time.”
Photo by Paul Mehaffey
Ashley Christensen, chef/proprietor, AC Restaurants
“100% chef Steven Greene + Herons at the Umstead. The detail in every layer of the experience is Michelin Star-deserving, from the meticulously selected ingredients (including running their own farm) to the high-level execution to the whimsical platings to the razor-sharp yet warm service. The minute there were rumblings of the Guide coming here, my immediate thought was, ‘Good! Steven deserves this!’”
To read our Q&A with a Michelin Guide North America Chief Inspector on how Stars are awarded, click here.