RM talks Tweedy,writing and the scene with the Raleigh rock band.
When Wilco’s Jeff Tweedy penned “I Am Trying to Break Your Heart” on acclaimed record Yankee Hotel Foxtrot, he unknowingly penned a Raleigh band into the city’s history books.
Alt-country group American Aquarium lifted their name from the opening line of the experimental rock track, launching a project that would eventually grow into a vast discography and 20+ years of live performances—garnering millions of ears, including the fans who now flock to the band’s annual Roadtrip to Raleigh, a three-night run at Lincoln Theatre kicking off Feb. 5.
“[Yankee Hotel Foxtrot] changed my life,” says frontman BJ Barham. “It changed how I viewed music and songwriting—it changed the way I viewed everything. It was a very easy decision to name the band American Aquarium—and, thankfully, 20 years later, Jeff Tweedy has not sued me, so I think he’s OK with it.”
Despite borrowing the Tweedy ref, the NC native doesn’t pursue the same abstract songwriting approach. While some American Aquarium tracks dip into conceptual narratives, Barham maintains their lyrics consistently draw from personal experience.
“If you put a piece of yourself in every song, every single time you sing it, you’re being honest with the audience,” Barham tells RM. “You can play it every night for 20 years and still have people believe you.” It’s an MO that serves the band well. Read: 16 albums in just two decades.
Still, the writing process doesn’t run on a fixed schedule—and results aren’t uniform. Barham says he will go a year without writing a song. “I make observations,” he explains. “I write down one-liners, songs and titles… nonsense I’ll overhear a couple talking about in Lincoln, Nebraska. Then I put all the observations down on the table and start drawing correlations. The songs present themselves.”
Barham isn’t sure a band like American Aquarium would find success in Raleigh today—and notes even they struggled in their own hometown early on.
“We’re not the math rock band, we’re not the indie punk band,” says the NC State grad. “We’re songwriters. For the first 10 years of our career, it was really hard to build something substantial in Raleigh—meaning bigger than The Pour House. We were selling out The Pour House every two months, but around the country, we were growing into larger theaters—we just weren’t growing in Raleigh.”
Enter Roadtrip to Raleigh. The band’s three-night run at Lincoln Theatre draws fans from all over the country for a hometown romp—and has consistently sold out over the decade.
“We take a lot of pride in where we’re from and where we got our start,” says Barham. “It’s always so nice to be able to come back home, bring all of our friends from around the country and show off how great Raleigh is.” So whether you’re a Raleigh native or Roadtrip regular, the road ends in the City of Oaks. lincolntheatre.com
Raleigh’s most over-the-top music tradition—a six-night, full-costume, secret-lineup spectacle—is getting the PBS NC treatment Aug. 21.
Raleigh’s rowdiest musical tradition is getting the big-screen treatment. The Great Cover Up—a documentary on the six-night, no-setlist, full-costume lovefest for live music at Kings—is premiering Aug. 21 on PBS NC.
It all started in 1999, when Kings co-founder Paul Siler and friends—touring musicians tired of the lack of indie-friendly venues—decided to open their own spot and throw a hurricane benefit. “A friend told us about this event where bands would dress up as a famous band and perform. We decided to make a curtain, not tell anybody who it was, and when the reveal happened, people just loved it,” Siler recalls. That two-night show is now a six-night festival with as many as 10 bands per night.
The rules? Learn a short set. Go all in on the costumes. Keep your band identity secret until the curtain drops. “The anticipation of who the next band is going to be is always fun,” muses Siler. “It’s an endless supply.”
Kings event manager Yvonne Chazal says the vibe is different from your typical dark-wall club. “We… know how to treat folks well… and the little things that make playing a show really comfortable,” she says. “We pride ourselves on throwing cool shows.”
Onstage, Siler emcees in his now-iconic ’70s-game-show-style jacket. Offstage, the Cover Up raises funds for multiple causes over the course of the week—past beneficiaries have included everything from the Red Cross to local soup kitchens.
The PBS NC documentary focuses on the people and the community that keep the tradition alive—longtime fans who’ve waited in line for decades, bands perfecting every note and wig flip, and even one first-time group prepping for their big reveal. For Siler, it’s a love letter to Raleigh: “It’s a cultural little slice of our city everybody gets excited about.” kingsraleigh.com
Raleigh is a music town—there, we said it. Fun fact: The City of Oaks ranks No. 2 in small concert venues per 100,000 residents with 5.9 venues per capita—more than twice as many as the average city. So it’s no surprise that musicians in Raleigh, and the rest of the Tar Heel State for that matter, are constantly churning out acclaimed tracks repping every genre. Here, some of our favorite tunes from the Old North State artists playing up the scene this year.
Rainbow Kitten Surprise is slated to have a jam-packed end to their year. After pulling out of their 2023 tour, the NC-based indie rock/pop band is back on the road following the release of their first album in six years and third ever, Love Hate Music Box. And what’s a tour without a visit home? The 35-stop North American tour incorporates two NC shows, including a Raleigh performance at the Lenovo Center Oct. 26.
Formed over a decade ago at Appalachian State University (s/o Boone!), the group has garnered millions of listeners and a steady following. But success hasn’t always been an easy road for the foursome—in the six years since the release of their 2018 album, How to: Friend, Love, Freefall, they’ve faced a slew of challenges, from mental health crises to creative differences and even a medical diagnosis that ultimately led them to cancel last year’s shows.
Now, the 2024 tour and release of Love Hate Music Box ushers in a new era for Rainbow Kitten Surprise. And with a new era comes a new sound—the 22-track album mulls over more fresh, poppier tunes than its previous indie-folk records. Here, we chat with Rainbow Kitten Surprise frontwoman Ela Melo about the natural progression of this sound, living in NC and giving back to their home state.
How has living in North Carolina impacted the Rainbow Kitten Surprise sound? North Carolina is the weird little gem of the south—the mountains, the beach and the vibes. We were never a part of any kind of scene, we just made what we made. There is an energy beneath it that is specific to the South. I feel it.
What influenced the drastic change in sound Love Hate Music Box reflects? I got kind of obsessed with the sound and that is the undercurrent of this record—not necessarily maximalist, but [a lot of instruments]. I’ve always had that in demos I’ve made, but with this one it was like, ‘let’s see how it goes.’ I think every record is a little bit different from the next one, and this one took six years to make. It’s a natural evolution of the band.
What artists have you been listening to recently? I haven’t been digging into much. I’ve been listening to that Mk.gee record, Two Star & The Dream Police. I just love his sound; his guitar is unbelievable. I get in a hole—especially when I’m writing—I just listen to what I’m working on because it feels like progress to figure out what I’m liking and what I’m not liking.
Are you already working on something new? It’s pretty much done with the last, on to the next. As soon as an album goes up for mastering I don’t really listen to it anymore and then I usually start [writing] right away.
Did Love Hate Music Box take six years to complete or was it a true hiatus? I don’t know how to not work. It’s a blessing and curse. But by the time we started really digging into what the tracks were to make this record, it took a year to complete. There were other versions of things that got [denied] over the years leading up to this record, and they may or may not see the light of day at some point. So yes, it took six years.
Tell us about the $50,000 Rainbow Kitten Surprise pledged to hurricane relief in Western North Carolina. We formed in Boone. We are from the mountains, lived there for seven or eight years and are [also] from other towns around Western North Carolina. Some of our friends and family just got power back a few days ago. Our hearts and thoughts are in North Carolina and I think about it every day. Pledging the $50K is just something we can do to help.
Answers have been lightly edited for length and clarity